This will render the scotus case moot unfortunately.
And now liberal activist judges who "had" to issue carry permits with restrictions will now have a fun new "premise only / strictly controlled unloaded transport permit" to issue.
So NY gun owners in most counties will be much worse off...
Well the rest of the country cares since this is the first real gun case in 10 years that could have national implications.
Otherwise the Safe act could easily follow you to whatever "safe haven" state you are fleeing to. Many so called gun friendly conservative states have fallen hard lately...
I don't think you quite understand the gravity if this case...It's not only about NYC...this is quite possibly the case where SCOTUS decides the level of scrutiny to be applied to 2nd amendment cases. If that happens, and we get strict scrutiny, goodbye NYC gun laws, goodbye SAFE Act, goodbye...
Apparently this could happen again once NYC actually implements their new bull$&^* rule illegally "allowing" premise holders to transport.
So once NYC makes their new "rule" SCOTUS could still toss the case...Which I really don't want to see happen. Hopefully SCOTUS is saying "a simple rule...
Well the state gets to appeal, but I doubt they will.
Bad news is, the liberal activist judge suggested that NY implement heavy restrictions on the ownership of them. Permitting systems only allowing them in the home or business. He actually suggested it to the state in his decision.
So not...
Our own NoloContendere (over on AR15.com) has been fighting the good fight in NY for over 2 years, and has finally WON!
MEMORANDUM-DECISION & ORDER that plaintiff's [52] Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED; Deft's [58] Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment is DENIED; New York Penal Law §...
Federal HydraShok is very outdated ammo...lots of studies show it getting gummed up by clothing and not penetrating near enough...
Speer Gold Dots, Winchester Rangers or Federal HSTs are much more effective.
See that is the thing...according to NYS law, a premise permit is only valid at the listed address. So a NYC premise holder IS breaking NYS law because the gun is not legal at their destination in NY (outside NYC).
So if NYC loses, NY will have to re-write NY PL400 to make premise permits valid...
People who think this is not an important case for the rest of the country need to understand the order of events of building precedent...
Heller and McDonald affirmed that:
Owning a gun is a fundamental individual right
Mandating it be locked up and unloaded / unusable at all times in the...
This is what I posted on ar15.com in GD...
OK so I know NYC's bullshit gun laws almost perfectly. Unfortunately.
This is MUCH bigger than most people think...here is why...
In NY (state and city), if you have a pistol permit, it is actually a CARRY PERMIT. Even if the county restricts it to...
Not sure what you are asking, but...
A NY CITY carry permit is good for carry in all of NY STATE. A NY STATE carry permit is NOT valid in NYC. Nice double standard huh?
A premise permit (either in NY or NYC) is ONLY valid for possession of the handgun at the address listed on the permit. No...
Well, we ARE being forced to hand over our HIPPA records in NY in order to exercise a fundamental right. So that IS unconstitutional. 100% illegal for them to require, since owning a gun is a fundamental right. But not according to NYS law.
Just like in Westchester and NYC where they make you...