Compliant build questions

JosERW

JosERW

.40 S&W
Messages
213
Reaction score
91
Location
Nassau County, NY
I'm doing a compliant build for a friend and we both have some questions. Since I don't really have any experience with compliant AR's I figured I'd ask here. So anyway, its between a standard AR with the FRS15 stock and an SCR. He's leaning SCR (it does actually look cool) but I have a few questions.

1) I know the forward assist is useless on the SCR but if I used an upper with the FA on, does it get in the way of your trigger finger when using a regular rifle stock?

2) One of the big reasons he is hesitant on the SCR is the lack of aftermarket parts. Like he likes that he can just drop any AR trigger in there. I know there isn't an aftermarket SCR trigger but has anybody done any trigger work to these with positive results?

3) This is more of a general opinion question, assuming the laws never change, do you think there will be aftermarket for the SCR? He likes the look of the SCR but doesn't like the stock or the fact that the bolt catch is removable. He has no problem building the SCR but he said he's taking a gamble that there will eventually be an aftermarket for stocks, sights, triggers, etc. Once their patent expires do you think we'll see other manufactures producing SCR lowers?

4) Anyone have any experience with a pinned and welded "fake" flash hider? GTG or should I just get a crowned barrel?

5) Any experience with the Gen 3 Thordsen stock? I think it looks ugly as sin. Is it that much better?

Thanks in advance. FUAC!
 
dsdmmat

dsdmmat

Donut Master
Moderator
Messages
10,630
Reaction score
23,365
Location
Alpha Quadrant, Sector 001
1) I know the forward assist is useless on the SCR but if I used an upper with the FA on, does it get in the way of your trigger finger when using a regular rifle stock?

No

2) One of the big reasons he is hesitant on the SCR is the lack of aftermarket parts. Like he likes that he can just drop any AR trigger in there. I know there isn't an aftermarket SCR trigger but has anybody done any trigger work to these with positive results?

The updated trigger pull is about 4.5 pounds, no aftermarket support as of yet.

3) This is more of a general opinion question, assuming the laws never change, do you think there will be aftermarket for the SCR? He likes the look of the SCR but doesn't like the stock or the fact that the bolt catch is removable. He has no problem building the SCR but he said he's taking a gamble that there will eventually be an aftermarket for stocks, sights, triggers, etc. Once their patent expires do you think we'll see other manufactures producing SCR lowers?

Very doubtful, the market for these guns are mainly based in the ban states most companies are not going to go after the few buyers in those states. The Stock from the Remington 1100 has been successfully adapted to the SCR. All the upper parts for standard ARs (sans the Bolt Carrier) are the same, only the lower components are unique to the SCR. The patents are not going to expire for about 16 more years who knows what is going to be happening by then.


4) Any experience with the Gen 3 Thordsen stock? I think it looks ugly as sin. Is it that much better?

No experience with Gen 3, took my Thordson off in favor of the spur. The ergonomics just didn't work for me.
 
JosERW

JosERW

.40 S&W
Messages
213
Reaction score
91
Location
Nassau County, NY
I've seen dozens of companies spring up with maglock products, I'm just wondering if anybody will develop some stocks for this thing. Even a modified Magpul or something. Rubber buttpad, spacers, cheek pieces, etc would make it much more comfortable to shoot I'm thinking.
 
togmaster

togmaster

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
12,873
Reaction score
19,014
Location
Buoy 42
5) Any experience with the Gen 3 Thordsen stock? I think it looks ugly as sin. Is it that much better?

I have both the gen 3 and the gen 2. The only difference with the gen 3 is they give you spacers which allow you to adjust your LOP. Other than that it is only aesthetics.
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

.950 JDJ
Messages
34,554
Reaction score
36,359
Location
Livingston
you have 2 options in NY .. fix the mag and do what you want and buy a speed loader or buy a Mini14 .. or have a UGLY AR ... ;)

 
Chuck D

Chuck D

.45 acp
Messages
433
Reaction score
438
Location
Rochester
I've used faux muzzle devices from Northern Gun Parts on my rifles. Pinned and welded on. They in essence are no different than a pinned and welded muzzle cap only they look better.

They've been seen by local and State LE that I shoot with, some friends, some not. To a person they've never said anything other than "where did you buy that from" and "that's cool, you have an extra one to sell me? "
 
Calculon

Calculon

.308 Win
Messages
4,549
Reaction score
8,877
Location
Dutchess
Chuck D said:
I've used faux muzzle devices from Northern Gun Parts on my rifles. Pinned and welded on. They in essence are no different than a pinned and welded muzzle cap only they look better.

They've been seen by local and State LE that I shoot with, some friends, some not. To a person they've never said anything other than "where did you buy that from" and "that's cool, you have an extra one to sell me? "
Click to expand...

I have 2 of the NGP faux muzzle devices on a couple builds. While they are aesthetic only, they look a lot better than a thread protector/cap IMHO. The folks at NGP machined this device specifically for NY with an OD of 0.74" so you could remove the gas block over the pinned hider if the block ever malfunctioned. Sandy and her husband who own the shop are nice folks. Buy a couple.

AR-.223 1/2-28 STEALTH-NY-CL-740 CLOSED-End, MOCK SLOTS (.375 exit) Barrel Extender-1
 
N

Newguyhere

.40 S&W
Messages
189
Reaction score
180
Location
Westchester
I built a rifle recently with the SCR lower. I was pleasantly pleased at the trigger. I have an original Thordsen stock sitting in the closet as I find the SCR is the best option for me.
 
JosERW

JosERW

.40 S&W
Messages
213
Reaction score
91
Location
Nassau County, NY
I actually worked with Sandy on their development of the 2.25" fake flash hiders for 14.5" barrels. I am just afraid to actually use them until there is 100% certainty they are legal. Technically it is still a "threaded" barrel.
 
Calculon

Calculon

.308 Win
Messages
4,549
Reaction score
8,877
Location
Dutchess
JosERW said:
What did you use to time the device BTW? A crush washer wouldn't allow the gas black to slide over it.
Click to expand...
Just saw this. Since it’s only for looks timing doesn’t really matter - i didn’t bother with a crush washer.
 
Phauxtoe

Phauxtoe

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,011
Reaction score
6,547
Location
Rockland
get a post ban A2 style gun with a monster man grip
I think its the least offensive compromise and only a little ugly.
detachable magazines are more important to me than a pistol grip or any other feature.
service match rifle copy.jpg
photoshopped depiction
 
Last edited:
Marine Cpl

Marine Cpl

.577 Tyrannosaur.
Messages
22,054
Reaction score
20,648
Location
Orange County
Phauxtoe said:
get a post ban A2 style gun with a monster man grip
I think its the least offensive compromise and only a little ugly.
detachable magazines are more important to me than a pistol grip or any other feature.
View attachment 40606
Click to expand...
That grip still protrudes. It works in CA because they define that a pistol grip allows the thumb to wrap around or something or the other. We have no definition.
 
Phauxtoe

Phauxtoe

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,011
Reaction score
6,547
Location
Rockland
Willjr75 said:
That grip still protrudes. It works in CA because they define that a pistol grip allows the thumb to wrap around or something or the other. We have no definition.
Click to expand...
i see your point about no NY definition, nobody wants to be the test case!
Vagueness is one of a tyrannical Governments tools!

(i was told about this by several LEO High Power shooters.)
 
Calculon

Calculon

.308 Win
Messages
4,549
Reaction score
8,877
Location
Dutchess
Phauxtoe said:
just curious, what makes you think FUAC brown shirts won't call that a muzzle devise.

i would 100% not put anything on the muzzle because you dont want to have to go to court to fight and prove it does nothing.
Remember, they down know anything
Click to expand...

Because it serves no purpose other than covering the threads which is required. It is not a break, hider or comp as it has no function. It’s a long thread protector.

Since nothing is spelled out how do we know a thread protector is gtg? How do we know monsterman is gtg? Thordsen? It gets rid of adjustable stock and protruding grip but is there a letter from NYSP giving it the thumbs up? Like many things with unSAFE we have to act in good faith to comply.
 
Phauxtoe

Phauxtoe

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,011
Reaction score
6,547
Location
Rockland
Calculon said:
Because it serves no purpose other than covering the threads which is required. It is not a break, hider or comp as it has no function. It’s a long thread protector.

Since nothing is spelled out how do we know a thread protector is gtg? How do we know monsterman is gtg? Thordsen? It gets rid of adjustable stock and protruding grip but is there a letter from NYSP giving it the thumbs up? Like many things with unSAFE we have to act in good faith to comply.
Click to expand...

hey i am on your side!
my point is if there is nothing on the end of your rifle, there is no interpretation needed.
some Ahole could say its a muzzle devise because its a Weight to help keep the recoil down.

its all up in the air until the laws change or its taken to court, yea sounds a lot like infringement!
 
Calculon

Calculon

.308 Win
Messages
4,549
Reaction score
8,877
Location
Dutchess
Phauxtoe said:
hey i am on your side!
my point is if there is nothing on the end of your rifle, there is no interpretation needed.
some Ahole could say its a muzzle devise because its a Weight to help keep the recoil down.

its all up in the air until the laws change or its taken to court, yea sounds a lot like infringement!
Click to expand...

Apologies if my response come off as snarky. Was not my intent. We’re all on same side.
 
Marine Cpl

Marine Cpl

.577 Tyrannosaur.
Messages
22,054
Reaction score
20,648
Location
Orange County
BDinPutnam said:
Well and also haven't there been some rabbit hole arguments about what "below" means?
Click to expand...
Yeah. I'll admit to being one of those guys trying to look the other way and pretend what below could mean to serve my purposes. I finally gave that up when I asked 3rd parities that know nothing about guns what they thought of the grips I had after showing them the law. These are the type of people that will be on the jury.
 
BDinPutnam

BDinPutnam

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
14,492
Reaction score
20,850
Location
Someplace else
Don't get me wrong Will I wasn't pointing a finger at you, I just remember those discussions (which a bunch of people were involved in).
 
Marine Cpl

Marine Cpl

.577 Tyrannosaur.
Messages
22,054
Reaction score
20,648
Location
Orange County
Well. I believe I was the main protagonist in that thread. I have no problems admitting so. I didn't take it that way from you but thought I'd fess up anyway.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top