Search results

  1. D

    S-6151 and S-6196 on Senate floor calendar

    This will render the scotus case moot unfortunately. And now liberal activist judges who "had" to issue carry permits with restrictions will now have a fun new "premise only / strictly controlled unloaded transport permit" to issue. So NY gun owners in most counties will be much worse off...
  2. D

    SCOTUS denies NYC request to hold off briefing

    Well the rest of the country cares since this is the first real gun case in 10 years that could have national implications. Otherwise the Safe act could easily follow you to whatever "safe haven" state you are fleeing to. Many so called gun friendly conservative states have fallen hard lately...
  3. D

    SCOTUS denies NYC request to hold off briefing

    I don't think you quite understand the gravity if this case...It's not only about NYC...this is quite possibly the case where SCOTUS decides the level of scrutiny to be applied to 2nd amendment cases. If that happens, and we get strict scrutiny, goodbye NYC gun laws, goodbye SAFE Act, goodbye...
  4. D

    SCOTUS denies NYC request to hold off briefing

    Apparently this could happen again once NYC actually implements their new bull$&^* rule illegally "allowing" premise holders to transport. So once NYC makes their new "rule" SCOTUS could still toss the case...Which I really don't want to see happen. Hopefully SCOTUS is saying "a simple rule...
  5. D

    Stun guns / Tasers now LEGAL in NY

    Well the state gets to appeal, but I doubt they will. Bad news is, the liberal activist judge suggested that NY implement heavy restrictions on the ownership of them. Permitting systems only allowing them in the home or business. He actually suggested it to the state in his decision. So not...
  6. D

    Stun guns / Tasers now LEGAL in NY

    Our own NoloContendere (over on AR15.com) has been fighting the good fight in NY for over 2 years, and has finally WON! MEMORANDUM-DECISION & ORDER that plaintiff's [52] Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED; Deft's [58] Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment is DENIED; New York Penal Law §...
  7. D

    Ammo? What does the fuzz use?

    Federal HydraShok is very outdated ammo...lots of studies show it getting gummed up by clothing and not penetrating near enough... Speer Gold Dots, Winchester Rangers or Federal HSTs are much more effective.
  8. D

    Supreme Court will hear New York gun rights case on transporting unloaded handguns

    See that is the thing...according to NYS law, a premise permit is only valid at the listed address. So a NYC premise holder IS breaking NYS law because the gun is not legal at their destination in NY (outside NYC). So if NYC loses, NY will have to re-write NY PL400 to make premise permits valid...
  9. D

    Supreme Court will hear New York gun rights case on transporting unloaded handguns

    People who think this is not an important case for the rest of the country need to understand the order of events of building precedent... Heller and McDonald affirmed that: Owning a gun is a fundamental individual right Mandating it be locked up and unloaded / unusable at all times in the...
  10. D

    One rifle or shotgun per 90 day period

    This is such BS.
  11. D

    One rifle or shotgun per 90 day period

    And how about lower receivers? Lol. Those are neither rifles, shotguns or pistols.
  12. D

    !! SCOTUS grants cert on NYC 2A infringement case!!

    This is what I posted on ar15.com in GD... OK so I know NYC's bullshit gun laws almost perfectly. Unfortunately. This is MUCH bigger than most people think...here is why... In NY (state and city), if you have a pistol permit, it is actually a CARRY PERMIT. Even if the county restricts it to...
  13. D

    Now Trumps a sell out and bans bump stocks.

    Yeah guys this is bad whether or not you "like" bump stocks or not. This is only the beginning of a slippery slope.
  14. D

    And yet then there is NYSRPA

    Not sure what you are asking, but... A NY CITY carry permit is good for carry in all of NY STATE. A NY STATE carry permit is NOT valid in NYC. Nice double standard huh? A premise permit (either in NY or NYC) is ONLY valid for possession of the handgun at the address listed on the permit. No...
  15. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Well, we ARE being forced to hand over our HIPPA records in NY in order to exercise a fundamental right. So that IS unconstitutional. 100% illegal for them to require, since owning a gun is a fundamental right. But not according to NYS law. Just like in Westchester and NYC where they make you...
  16. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Lol so Edward, if that is the case, you are correct...but NOT for the reason you thought you were correct. Ha. But it's a moot point if it's part of a regular background check record. Nowhere in PL400 would it warrant HIPPA access if being involuntarily committed is known without HIPPA records.
  17. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Well shit if that is the case, I reverse my opinion 100%. But if HIPPA etc. is the only way to prove yourself innocent, I do still believe the law "allows" for it (albeit unconstitutional).
  18. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Good for you for fighting Edward. And winning. Now wait...does it require a HIPPA investigation to prove you haven't been involuntarily committed? If that kind of thing shows up on a regular background check, and doesn't require you to sign away your health privacy HIPPA rights...then I am...
  19. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    If PL400 only said "the applicant must state under penalty of perjury that they have never been committed" - then yes, Edward, you would be correct. But it says that the applicant can not have ever been committed...Not that we have to STATE we haven't. So it implies we have to prove ourselves...
  20. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    OK good debate...and I am sorry you had to resort to insulting me... But I think we are both right in some areas... PL400 does NOT say we HAVE to give up our medical records. You are 100% correct. PL400 does IMPLY that we have to prove ourselves innocent and worthy to get a permit. So if we...
  21. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    No...FFLs can't ask for HIPPA forms or take drug tests. The 4473 requires that the buyer make statements under penalty of perjury. Again it's because NY is MAY issue...you have to prove yourself worthy before the king gives you your rights. If we were SHALL issue, THEY would have to prove you...
  22. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    And Edward...I am not one to give in to NY laws...I am always the first to tell people that their pistol permit "restrictions" are illegal and mean nothing. I am the first to tell people that home inspections and safety classes are NOT in PL400 and are therefore illegal. When it's not in the...
  23. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Yikes...Edward...haha. Calm down man. The point is...NY is MAY issue. Meaning, if you don't PROVE yourself to be qualified per PL400, they CAN deny you. Trust me, it is unconstitutional that we are guilty until proven innocent when trying to exercise our rights...and NY's MAY issue laws need...
  24. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Edward...In no way did I ever personally insult or attack you. We were debating the finer points of a confusing law. Why the personal insult? We are on the same side here man. Just debating a dumb law. No need to be angry or rude.
  25. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Ha. Edward...I've been a member of AR15.com and the now somewhat defunct NYFIREARMS websites since 2005...same screen name. We've been over these laws many times over the past 13 years. I am not some newbie that just joined the internet gun forum world. Ha. Laws don't always have to explicitly...
  26. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Edward...you are wrong here. It is not the same as making STATEMENTS on a 4473. Those are your WORD. No further investigation required or mandated by the law. But if PL400 says you can't be addicted to drugs, and that you can't have been committed...then that implies (spirit of the law) that...
  27. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Well wait...does it say that the applicant must simply STATE that they are not addicted? Or does it say that the applicant CAN NOT BE addicted? If the latter, that implies a drug test could be required...
  28. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Well according to the law, I think they could also require a drug test to prove you aren't addicted. Again, unconstitutional, but it is in the spirit of the law. If PL400 gives a requirement that IS able to be investigated, the county can ask for HIPPA and drug tests etc. Until NYS is forced...
  29. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Not that I agree with signing away HIPPA rights AT ALL...but how else would they confirm that you have not been involuntarily committed, other than giving them access to your mental health records? According to what I highlighted in red, you have to STATE that you have not suffered any mental...
  30. D

    Washington State is worse than NY now.

    Other than the 9 month wait, getting a full carry in Monroe County was easy. Plus, no questions asked when adding an AR lower to a pistol permit (because it's legal). The clerks are all very PRO gun in Monroe. As are the Sheriffs. I do believe I had to sign a form letting them look into my...
Top