Judge didn't screw up. This is intentional refusal to follow the Supreme Court's decision. Basically doing what NY did. Gave the Supreme Court the middle finger. Another far left wing fanatic on the bench deciding how she wants the law to be. Who appointed her and when.? I haven't looked her up.
Yes, I know it is in theory better to stay and fight. I have fought some in court, but I'm old and want to spend the rest of the time I have left to live in relative freedom. You just get worn out with this crap. And it just keeps getting worse. But you folks keep up the good fight.
Having retired and decamped to Florida except for one case still pending in NY, I find Florida's proposed gun legislation totally different. Right now the big issue is Florida is whether constitutional carry bill pending in the legislature will be concealed carry or both concealed carry and...
From a lawyer's view point, it is always better to have Supreme Court authority to support your case. I know it is frustrating. There have been at least five positive gun rights decisions in NY since Bruen. NY does not recognize the 2nd Amendment or the Supreme Court if it disagrees with it's...
Re NYC. Think about it. Even if your up state permit is no good in NYC, there is a provision to get an NYC endorsement to carry in NYC. Since it is now "shall issue" can't use "good moral character" etc, very limited discretion, I think if you applied for the endorsement, they would have to...
Ok, my guess was a day early. Came out Monday instead of Friday. Most of the absolutely horrible stuff was thrown out in this decision. On Friday you will have a real carry permit, unless the 2nd intervenes. More cases will be filed re the subways, public transportation etc. I think the school...
I am a lawyer and have handled several "gun cases" in NY. In most cases, legal questions are decided on the briefs and the judge's (actually law clerk's) research in addition to the briefs. Don't even have oral arguments in many cases. Legal opinions don't write themselves. They, as well as the...
Excellent opinion. Sets out the proper test for standing. His findings would apply equally to most of the CCIA. It is so clear cut, just a matter of time before the CCIA is gone. Then of course replaced with an equally unconstitutional law. The state of NY is acting like Alabama and Mississippi...
Zelenski probably has all kinds of info/evidence re activity of the Biden crime family in Ukraine. He is using this to blackmail Biden into providing him with what he wants. Otherwise he does a document dump just before mid-terms. Then threatens with same dump before 2024. It is the Biden crime...
arp228, I have read the entire decision. Have not set down and outlined or marked up etc. I think the judge was careful. He allowed some parts to stand as restricted temporary areas etc. I think the training requirement is burdensome, but he decided to let it stand "for now.". Schools and govt...
Judge Suddaby has already given his opinion on the constitutional status of the law. He knows this case will be appealed to the Second Circuit and then the Supreme Court. He and his law clerks are carefully crafting the decision to hold up on appeal. I think we will have a decision by the end of...
You have the Federal Rules, then the Local Rules, then the Judge's Rules and the ECF Clerks rules. So it is easy to run afoul of one of these rules. Usually not fatal to the case, but causes delays. Especially easy if you are concerned with the substance of the case and don't pay meticulous...
CaliberPlus, Yes I practice is NY but am trying to retire. Only two cases left (not gun cases). There is a lawyer I can recommend re gun cases. They have gotten a lot easier since Buren. And tirwin1, your are right, the judge could do it, but not going to happen. I agree.
I think in view of...