This is one of several reasons why plaintiffs should not seek preliminary injunctions. They should apply for a permanent injunction up front. Even though it is a more rigorous process, and will take longer, if this were involving a permanent injunction, SCOTUS may have granted cert.
Mandate recalled by 2nd Circuit.
Translation: Everything we (2nd Circuit) did after Suddaby is void.
Case returned to jurisdiction of 2nd to be re-litigated in light of Rahimi.
Bottom line: most of CCIA void as per Suddaby's decision. What Suddaby wrote is now operative law (for now).
Stay...
There is a case in which this was part of the conversation. I heard the audio but don't know the name of the case.
It's the guy who wants to open carry on the Utica Ave stop of the A Train. Female attorney.
2nd Circus said that NYC licenses are BG-checked every 2 years and upstate are issued...
https://www.foundationforasaferny.com/updates/nypd-080624-emergency-rule
NYPD 08.06.24 EMERGENCY RULE
On 08.06.24 NYPD issued an emergency rule in regards to the issuance of concealed carry permits, that has made several updates to the way they operate.
The key takeaways are as...
Non-resident carry licenses seem to be untouched, and they added three positives:
1) a non-resident with a license from their home state (for example a NY license, but no MA license) can 'car carry' similar to Illinois if driving through (locked glove box at rest areas),
2) carrying on an...
If anyone is looking for the 2nd Circuit ruling that was vacated by SCOTUS, here it is:
https://www.2ampatriot.com/publications/p/antonyuk-v-chiumento-2d-cir-ruling-12082023
No, it's not the current governing ruling, the listing has not been updated, but the entire 263 pages is at the link, free.
They have to be seen as 'doing something.' So Ghost Guns are next on the list of things to pick on.
Problem is, Hochul and James make a rookie mistake and picked on something definable; a 'lawfully carried self defense handgun.' And so they lost. The GVR was a solid loss for the state, don't...
Attorney General James Announces Ban on Having 'Woody' in New York
NEW YORK - Attorney General James announced a ban on the NRA having "Woody" in New York. In February, a jury found the NRA liable for not managing their Woody and ordered them to pay damages. New Yorkers need to know that we...
OK, well that's good. Judge Suddaby will issue a ruling, however temporary, in Antonyuk's favor, sometime after he gets the status report and prior to the 2nd Circuit decision expiring as per the mandate from SCOTUS.
In the mean time, I can still carry in Home Depot.
I have not looked into it, because the tires do not hit the road with those cases, and I am not getting paid as an attorney. Antonyuk affects our carry rights in real time.
Did you read anything I wrote above? I am not a lawyer, but what I posted was researched and cited using impeccable logic. Hand wringing and blanket statements such as 'we are so screwed' do nothing positive. Know the law and act accordingly.
Read Antonyuk's Petition for Grant of Ceriorari...
EXCERPTS FROM:
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI - FEB 20,2024
ANTONYUK V. JAMES
Page 8 - Key concepts here are 'granting preliminary relief' which means 'we got what we asked for' and in effect 'could I have that back, please.' This is to demonstrate to SCOTUS that if I win, this is what I...
First off, these are the words of one of those pool reporters from a local rag. That's how they write things; they know nothing of the subject, they don't want to know, so they say things like 'did not appear to.'
And the article quotes an un-named and un-credentialed 'spokesperson' (who could...
I was picking on a kid I thought I could beat, but he kicked my ass. His name was Antonyuk.
So I will find another kid to pick on.
That's what that press release screams of.
Notice that the CCIA was not mentioned AT ALL, even in the summary of her accomplishments in the last paragraph.