9th Circuit Hi-Cap Mag Review

[Edwardteach72]

Someone would have to appeal the circuit ruling.

CA *might* appeal the ruling if they lost, but if they think they'll lose again at SCOTUS they might just decide not to risk it.

If CA doesn't appeal it, then nobody else can. You can't appeal a case you won, and I think the NY cases were too long ago or were already denied cert.

The best case for us might actually be to lose in the 9th circus and then we can appeal to SCOTUS for sure. Possibly with another Trump appointee in place of RBG.

Denied cert and NY never appealed the 2nds decision on 10 rounds

 

[Chevusa]

Yes, but that was a 3 judge panel. En Banc, I don’t see the 9th doing anything to support 2A.

Not sure about that. The ruling came and they were legal until it was challenged by the state. People were buying and selling them. There is now a stay in force meaning the decision would need to be reversed to make illegal again.

 

[Edwardteach72]

Not sure about that. The ruling came and they were legal until it was challenged by the state. People were buying and selling them. There is now a stay in force meaning the decision would need to be reversed to make illegal again.

En Banc - Google Search

www.google.com

 

[Chevusa]

En Banc - Google Search

www.google.com

I'd need to look up the details of the progress and what stage it's in. Not sure what's been ruled on so far, but it was legal for a time until a stay was issued. Seems like they would make a final determination before people would have been allowed to buy and sell them.

 

[Robin]

I have it on good authority that in western NY, 7 is arbitrary and 10 is not. This has been backed up by either the Hague or Mother Earth News, I can't remember which.
Robin Skretney