What happened at the emergency SCOTUS meeting today?

S

spb1122

9mm
Messages
85
Reaction score
141
Location
new york
Deplorable Me said:
SCOTUS has denied the application for a stay of the NYS ammunition law. Appears that it wasn't properly presented.
Click to expand...
Where did you find the indication of why it was denied?

ETA: @Deplorable Me , to clarify; What did you find that indicates that it "Appears that it wasn't properly presented."?
I haven't found any explanations for the denial, but would like to read them if they exist.
 
Last edited:
S

spb1122

9mm
Messages
85
Reaction score
141
Location
new york
ManualF150 said:
Pages 14-16 of this: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/101023zor_5i26.pdf
Click to expand...
Pages 14 thru 16 are about an entirely different case, aren't they (DON BLANKENSHIP v. NBCUNIVERSAL, LLC, ET AL.)?

23A230 GAZZOLA, NADINE, ET AL. V. HOCHUL, GOV. OF NY, ET AL. is the case we are watching. The only mention of this case (that I see) is on page 1:
23A230
GAZZOLA, NADINE, ET AL. V. HOCHUL, GOV. OF NY, ET AL.
The application for stay addressed to Justice Thomas and
referred to the Court is denied.
 
Robin

Robin

.577 Tyrannosaur.
Messages
20,651
Reaction score
44,793
Location
Livingston County
The three branches of our government, Executive, Legislative, and Judicial.
Question: In which branch of the government are its members sworn to protect and defend the constitution of the United States of America?
Answer: Apparently, none of them!
Robin
 
stokes

stokes

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,939
Reaction score
15,104
Location
Columbia County,NY
This is exactly why I never get my hopes up about these lawsuits. Even when they side with us ala Bruen, they just find a way around it as we saw here with the CCIA. I really have little hope anymore that the 2A will survive, I dont know what the solution could be, but apparently the law and Constitution are dead.
 
R

REF

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
1,556
Reaction score
3,391
Location
Nassau
stokes said:
This is exactly why I never get my hopes up about these lawsuits. Even when they side with us ala Bruen, they just find a way around it as we saw here with the CCIA. I really have little hope anymore that the 2A will survive, I dont know what the solution could be, but apparently the law and Constitution are dead.
Click to expand...
^^^^^So true. I will not ever give up but I’m also a realist. Certain people on here were saying “But Bruen, but Bruen ……” and that we’re naysayers, , for lack of a better term. No , we just see through the bullshit. As long as there are no repercussions for states blatantly circumventing SC rulings, it’s a lost cause. Unless politicians and legislators are held accountable for passing unconstitutional laws, nothing will change. And if anyone here thinks that NYS, sorry NFS (no fun state) will just sit back and let you exercise your 2nd amendment rights like the majority of other states do , needs to get their heads out of their asses and wake up.
 
W

Willyone

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,158
Reaction score
3,982
Location
Elbridge, NY
As gun owners we have two main problems, other than the obvious Albany issues...
1) we're out numbered by non owners.
2) not enough gun owners and or non gun owners give a shit about 2A rights.
 
C

CaliberPlus

.45 acp
Messages
441
Reaction score
820
Location
Mannsville, NY
I have to admit, my view is pretty sour. Gets more so with every BG check. I had a glimmer of hope, not so much.

Here is an excerpt from the email I recieved from Paloma A. Cappana (hope it is ok to list here)

SCOTUS: “Denied.”​

This morning, as part of the case conference announcement packet, the Plaintiffs and I learned that our “Emergency Application” to the Hon. Justice Clarence Thomas of September 12, 2023 was denied. There was no accompanying statement or opinion. The denial neither grants our request for relief, nor expressly supports the defendants’ actions.
As a procedural matter, the broader motion from which the 3-prong sub-motion was derived is still pending at the Second Circuit. We now likely must wait until whenever the Second Circuit panel judges decide to rule on our broader motion for preliminary injunctive relief. In the context of the lawsuit as a whole, this motion is “just” the first motion in the case.


 
thughes

thughes

.223 Rem
Messages
1,031
Reaction score
2,852
Location
Your Mom's house
CaliberPlus said:
I
​
SCOTUS: “Denied.”​
​

This morning, as part of the case conference announcement packet, the Plaintiffs and I learned that our “Emergency Application” to the Hon. Justice Clarence Thomas of September 12, 2023 was denied. There was no accompanying statement or opinion. The denial neither grants our request for relief, nor expressly supports the defendants’ actions.
As a procedural matter, the broader motion from which the 3-prong sub-motion was derived is still pending at the Second Circuit. We now likely must wait until whenever the Second Circuit panel judges decide to rule on our broader motion for preliminary injunctive relief. In the context of the lawsuit as a whole, this motion is “just” the first motion in the case.

Click to expand...
tl;dnr: "10-20 years from now you may get some relief....or not" :rolleyes:
 
Cooolone

Cooolone

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,298
Reaction score
9,754
Location
NY, USA
Well... The founders didn't create those Rights, they just recognized them... Our Rights are not defined by paper, or gavels hitting the bench!

I'll exercise my Right as I see fit, thank you very much! No need for validation by some court... Or invalidation by some political hack!

"Shall Not Be INFRINGED"

End of conversation...

Besides, in about 90 days or so, I'll be living in another state while my new abode is built! Away from this fucking cesspool of a State that shits all over it's constituents!
 
Grimscale

Grimscale

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,131
Reaction score
15,929
Location
Rochester
Acer-m14 said:
i guess someone is going to have to sell a box of ammo with no background check and get caught so they have fuckin standing
Click to expand...
Still won't matter. It'll just get lumped in with the existing lawsuits and remain on hold, effectively ending our Rights.

Cooolone said:
I'll exercise my Right as I see fit, thank you very much
Click to expand...
Good luck with that.
Unless you can build your own from raw materials apparently no company will sell to us here in New York, even companies from actual free states.

I can't say I'm surprised the S.C. refused to enforce their own rulings. That dog apparently hasn't had teeth in centuries.
 
Cavalry

Cavalry

.338 Win Mag
Messages
5,167
Reaction score
9,043
Location
Behind Enemy Lines
Grimscale said:
Good luck with that.
Unless you can build your own from raw materials apparently no company will sell to us here in New York, even companies from actual free states.
Click to expand...
The interwebs are expansive and full of companies that do not give a shit. I am very confident that I could have anything that is legal elsewhere shipped to an address in NY.
 
Z

Zerex

.308 Win
Messages
3,299
Reaction score
2,569
Location
Rome, NY
I got an email from the atty, as I contributed $25 bucks.

Denied, with no opinion or documentation at all...............sent back down to the 2nd Circuit Court that has totally ignored Bruen.............if 2nd Circuit refuses to act it may take decades.............

Something has to break at SCOTUS.........
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
36,654
Reaction score
41,037
Location
Western NY
Acer-m14 said:
i guess someone is going to have to sell a box of ammo with no background check and get caught so they have fuckin standing
Click to expand...
I don’t understand why every person in America doesn’t have standing for this if that’s their issue. Anyone can come to nys and buy ammo so it impacts every citizen 18 and up.
 
Defilade

Defilade

.700 Nitro Express
Messages
26,625
Reaction score
38,282
Location
Elsewhere
Looks like SCOTUS got a talking to from their handlers. It's a no Brainerd that this is Unconstitutional
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top