History is Unerring, Redundant and Unforgiving: Parallels of 1917 Bolshevik Revolution to 2020 Leftist Rebellion

[ProgSpear]

They don’t care about the actual election results.

History is Unerring, Redundant and Unforgiving: The Shocking Parallels of the 1917 Russian Bolshevik Revolution to 2020 US Leftist Rebellion | The Gateway Pundit | by Jim Hoft

Guest post by John L.

www.thegatewaypundit.com

 

[Catskillkid]

I re-read Animal Farm recently. It's scary the parallels that you see between that fable and this moment in history.

Always remember comrades, all animals are equal. Some are just more equal than others.

 

[BerettaGuy]

They don’t care about the actual election results.

History is Unerring, Redundant and Unforgiving: The Shocking Parallels of the 1917 Russian Bolshevik Revolution to 2020 US Leftist Rebellion | The Gateway Pundit | by Jim Hoft

Guest post by John L.

www.thegatewaypundit.com

Great article thank you for posting. I sent to my family saying read the article or watch Dr. Ziviago, both come to the same conclusion.

Bad times are ahead.

I don't think the American public is prepared for it. We have several generations of people that don't know how to take a crap without a toilet. They are used to Strawberries in January. They are like the aristocracy of Russia living the good life. They worry about silly things like genderless bathrooms and other such nonsense. They will be the first to "cave" when the SHTF. They will march quietly to the death camps in hope of security and will turn in their own blood for a hot meal.

 

[ProgSpear]

I suspect the FEMA camps won’t be bothered doling out various meds that some of us seasoned citizens need, so marching quietly is not high on my list. Besides, my knees hurt too much to do any marching.

 

[Mosinitis]

Another bullshit article, by people who never learned, don't know and don't understand history. Propaganda for simple minded.

 

[Mosinitis]

American problems are rooted in American history, American society, American values and American culture. It has nothing to do with "ism" ideologies. Not with left "isms" not with right "isms.

 

[Mosinitis]

Lets blame the Bolshevicks for crony Capitalism. Lets blame Stalin for gender confusion and idiotic pride in it.

 

[Mosinitis]

This stupidity is nauseating. Ignorant preaching to the dumb.

 

[spat]

Lets blame the Bolshevicks for crony Capitalism. Lets blame Stalin for gender confusion and idiotic pride in it.

Nobody is blaming Stalin for our current problems.

They are saying beware because an American Stalin is coming.

History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes, and the tune they are playing in the United States today seems awfully familiar.

 

[Mosinitis]

Nobody is blaming Stalin for our current problems.

They are saying beware because an American Stalin is coming.

History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes, and the tune they are playing in the United States today seems awfully familiar.

American reality has no parallels to Russian reality. Stalin would never come to power in America and Russia wouldn't be on the map today without Stalin.

 

[ProgSpear]

OK, we get it. You are a Soviet/Stalin/Bolshevik/Statist apologist. Over and over and over and over... Anyone who cites any history you disagree with is an idiot. Hells bells, you should register as a Democrat.

Incidentally, in case you missed it, the point here is that tyranny was not part of the American Founding, or it’s experience, until the progressive movement (Fabian socialists) started undermining the constitutional republic. The difference between the Fabian socialists and the Bolsheviks was basically their degree of patience.

I know, you’ll give me the line about how Lincoln was the original tyrant on the American scene, invasion of the south, yadda yadda, but the progressive era was when the whole thing really started to fall apart. The sedition act, the creation of the Fed, etc. were all the lead in to the massive intrusion of the state during the 30’s, which happened to be the period when Stalin enforced the massive intrusion of the state on the Russian people, including the Holodomor, (which of course you will deny occurred). Flatly, the excesses of the left are being replicated today, if not in exact detail, then in intent, and for you to deny it or be an apologist for it is reprehensible.

The growth of the American Empire is almost exclusively a Democrat enterprise, except for when Republican Progressives (a.k.a. Lefty Lights) supported the program. Since the left cannot learn from their failures in the past (consider the whole Stalin/FDR thing was in the 30’s, and they still haven’t learned anything about reality) then they will ultimately learn the hard way. I personally am old enough that I will never see the day when it actually occurs, but I can fervently wish for them to lose once again...

The Fourth Turning continues.

 

[BerettaGuy]

Besides, my knees hurt too much to do any marching.

Mine too but I can maintain a rearguard action with the best of them.

 

[Mosinitis]

You are a product of a system where two camps of ignorant idiots are twisting world history to justify their own indoctrination. Your whole view of the world history is through a narrow ideological prism. No consideration is given to realities of the time period. Self serving spin and propaganda above else. The whole fucking world revolves around comical American purse fight. Your knowledge of world history doesn't go beyond selective factoids and gross exaggerations that support your point.
It's pathetic.

 

[Mosinitis]

and this is not harmless. How did Democracy in the Middle East worked out? This is what happens when ignorant idiots are trying to control the world.

 

[Mosinitis]

The beacon of freedom against the world filled with evil dictators. Tell me this is not indoctrination. No respect for other cultures, their history, their concerns. We know better how you should live.

 

[prambo]

OK, we get it. You are a Soviet/Stalin/Bolshevik/Statist apologist. Over and over and over and over... Anyone who cites any history you disagree with is an idiot. Hells bells, you should register as a Democrat.

Incidentally, in case you missed it, the point here is that tyranny was not part of the American Founding, or it’s experience, until the progressive movement (Fabian socialists) started undermining the constitutional republic. The difference between the Fabian socialists and the Bolsheviks was basically their degree of patience.

I know, you’ll give me the line about how Lincoln was the original tyrant on the American scene, invasion of the south, yadda yadda, but the progressive era was when the whole thing really started to fall apart. The sedition act, the creation of the Fed, etc. were all the lead in to the massive intrusion of the state during the 30’s, which happened to be the period when Stalin enforced the massive intrusion of the state on the Russian people, including the Holodomor, (which of course you will deny occurred). Flatly, the excesses of the left are being replicated today, if not in exact detail, then in intent, and for you to deny it or be an apologist for it is reprehensible.

The growth of the American Empire is almost exclusively a Democrat enterprise, except for when Republican Progressives (a.k.a. Lefty Lights) supported the program. Since the left cannot learn from their failures in the past (consider the whole Stalin/FDR thing was in the 30’s, and they still haven’t learned anything about reality) then they will ultimately learn the hard way. I personally am old enough that I will never see the day when it actually occurs, but I can fervently wish for them to lose once again...

The Fourth Turning continues.

I don't know where it is in the Bible, but I do remember the lines...

"For the Lord so despised communist trolls, that he did create the "Ignore Button" on NYGF."

"And it was good, and the members thereof hearkened to its use, and doth find peace in that."

"And the use of the "Ignore Button" increased from its loins, so that peace did prevail upon the forum."

"And the Lord did remindeth the members - "Do not suffer a troll amongst thee, but cast him out."

Or something like that.....

 

[Steal2B]

 

[Mosinitis]

View attachment 105890

Prove or show that he ever said that. It's routine in this country to make up quotes and attribute them to world leaders without any evidence.

 

[Mosinitis]

This is exactly what I was talking about. Stalin would never put these two paragraphs together. It defies logic and yet there is no problem with throwing it out there without any evidence.

 

[Steal2B]

Prove or show that he ever said that. It's routine in this country to make up quotes and attribute them to world leaders without any evidence.

Snopes agreed that Stalin believed this but did not find where he said it, however, Facebook fact checkers approved it and left the meme.

I won't bother questioning the Devine Facebook fact checkers. Give them a call. Knock yourself out.

 

[Mosinitis]

Snopes agreed that Stalin believed this but did not find where he said it, however, Facebook fact checkers approved it and left the meme.

I won't bother questioning the Devine Facebook fact checkers. Give them a call. Knock yourself out.

Snopes knows what was inside Stalin's head word for word. This is laughable.

 

[Steal2B]

Snopes knows what was inside Stalin's head word for word. This is laughable.

Give them a call, knock yourself out. They probably like him too. It'll be fun. Keep us posted.

 

[Mosinitis]

I am thinking back, trying to find anything false that Soviet propaganda said about American presidents or American history and you know something. I can't come up with anything. In this country it's routine to make stuff up. It starts with our internal politics and when it comes to world history, there is no one really to set the record straight.

 

[ProgSpear]

@Mosinitis , You didn’t even remotely attempt to answer my assertion regarding the excesses of the left, instead you predictably veered into a defense of the past excesses of the Soviet era. Mere assertions that “ It starts with our internal politics and when it comes to world history, there is no one really to set the record straight.” simply don’t cut it, especially when Soviet apologists like the NYT are pushing revisionist history like the “1619 Project”. These were the same people that were the apologists for Stalin. History is to a degree subjective, but at some point should have some measure of truth interjected.

EDIT: I am not denigrating the sacrifices the Russian people made during the “Great Patriotic War”, nor am I minimizing the stupidities exhibited by the Kennedy/Johnson and Bush/Clinton/Bush/Obama years, but hey, it is what it is...

 

[BerettaGuy]

 

[Mosinitis]

@Mosinitis , You didn’t even remotely attempt to answer my assertion regarding the excesses of the left, instead you predictably veered into a defense of the past excesses of the Soviet era. Mere assertions that “ It starts with our internal politics and when it comes to world history, there is no one really to set the record straight.” simply don’t cut it, especially when Soviet apologists like the NYT are pushing revisionist history like the “1619 Project”. These were the same people that were the apologists for Stalin. History is to a degree subjective, but at some point should have some degree of truth interjected.

American left is a product of American society. It has nothing to do with the history of Russia or communist ideology. Stalin was our ally. Without Stalin there wouldn't be WWII victory and chances are you would be typing this in German.There is nothing really to apologize for.
1619 project doesn't ring a bell I will have to research it to comment.

 

[Mosinitis]

1619 project makes my point. There is no respect for historical facts and accuracy in this country. The left is doing it even more than the right.

The 1619 Project - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

 

[ProgSpear]

American left is a product of American society. It has nothing to do with the history of Russia or communist ideology. Stalin was our ally. Without Stalin there wouldn't be WWII victory and chances are you would be typing this in German.There is nothing really to apologize for.
1619 project doesn't ring a bell I will have to research it to comment.

Again, I think you are distorting the history. Bolshevik communism was international communism. I think it was the 1926 (may have the year wrong) Comintern that laid out the 43 points by which they would bring down the west in general, and the US specifically, and the American left was assiduously fostered by the Soviets. You can argue that somehow Stalin saved the world, but the reality is that without the industrial power of the US, the “motherland” would have gone down to the “fatherland”, but we would still be here, although we would have not achieved the same empire. Without the influence of the “motherland” we would likely not have the internal subversion we have suffered from for the last 50 years, however.

 

[Steal2B]

They don’t care about the actual election results.

History is Unerring, Redundant and Unforgiving: The Shocking Parallels of the 1917 Russian Bolshevik Revolution to 2020 US Leftist Rebellion | The Gateway Pundit | by Jim Hoft

Guest post by John L.

www.thegatewaypundit.com

The Neo-Bolshevik Takeover of America Has Already Happened

Whoever is running America, they are not in DC. Your elected officials have surrendered the levers of power; some sold them, others just failed to protect them

americaoutloud.com

 

[Mosinitis]

Again, I think you are distorting the history. Bolshevik communism was international communism. I think it was the 1926 (may have the year wrong) Comintern that laid out the 43 points by which they would bring down the west in general, and the US specifically, and the American left was assiduously fostered by the Soviets. You can argue that somehow Stalin saved the world, but the reality is that without the industrial power of the US, the “motherland” would have gone down to the “fatherland”, but we would still be here, although we would have not achieved the same empire. Without the influence of the “motherland” we would likely not have the internal subversion we have suffered from for the last 50 years, however.

Originally Communist doctrine called for worldwide revolution. Rebellion of the opressed classes around the world. There was nothing that singled out U.S. This is the reason they gave away so much of their territory to Germany when they pulled out of WWI. They didn't think it mattered in the long run. They quickly realized worldwide revolution is not going to happen and they have their own issues to deal with. It was actually Stalin who lead the faction that took more progmatic approach. You are forgetting all of the efforts by Western powers to destroy Soviet Russia from day one.
Arguably this went on for centuries and continues to this day, no matter which system is in place there. To your point, the left of today is not connected to Comintern in any way, shape or form. Comintern sezed to exist in 1943 and was abandoned long before that.
Soviet Union had an excellent record of fighting against Colonialism. The world will remember that. They stood on the right side of history on this, we didn't.