Handgun falls out of man's pocket while he's on ride at Boonville-Oneida County Fair

Bustedknees · Friday at 7:04 PM

They'll have to drop the charges or fight their illegal gun free zone.

Saltwater60 · Friday at 8:53 PM

Dang shame. Don’t know him but clearly not criminal of the year but now he is. I hope it goes to a jury trial and the jury takes matters into their own hands. I’d find him not guilty of criminal possession of a weapon. He has a permit.

JunkBoxFull · Saturday at 7:12 AM

I hope he`s not a implant by some anti-gun organization of some sort to have a fake "GOT`CHA" moment. How well are the police known in that area, are they hard-asses? Seems they could have just got ahold of the guy and give him a warning and give him his firearm back, IF, he has a permit. Do we even know for sure that he even has a permission slip from the government to have a firearm? I dunno, seems there is a lot more to this story than what has been reported. A lot of " we don`t know what we don`t know" with this story. I`ll wait to see what plays out. If this was dirty, it will disappear in a flash.

This "Gun Free Zone" bullsh!t needs to be squashed. But, once again, here we are, with New York`s stupid fukking law makers winning, again.

togmaster · Saturday at 7:43 AM

Doc8404 said:
I’m not one to speculate. But why would he not go after his gun? Perhaps he was drinking? No idea. Someone on this board must know the guy but why would you not go back for your gun. And if anyone says, “maybe he didn’t know he lost it,” I won’t say “then maybe he should not have a gun.”

Because I know that would get people up in arms.

Not me. There are plenty of people that are too stupid to have guns.

Holland · Saturday at 11:32 AM

The only "justifiable" reason for a gun-free zone is when there is overriding security ie: government buildings where everyone walks through a metal detector and there is a large police presence. Even then, the Erie County Hall allows you to check your weapon at the door lest you have to walk the streets downtown unarmed. All these gun free zones without force protection in place create are soft targets

Beerman · Saturday at 1:01 PM

Doc8404 said:
Because I know that would get people up in arms.

And maybe, just maybe, some of *those* people shouldn’t have guns, either. :beer:

OwnTheRide · Saturday at 2:16 PM

togmaster said:
Not me. There are plenty of people that are too stupid to have guns.

Beerman said:
And maybe, just maybe, some of *those* people shouldn’t have guns, either.

Holy shit, am I on a gun-grabber forum? Have we learned nothing? Opening the door to gun control is akin to opening the floodgates.

You guys aren't wrong, per se: some people are too stupid to have guns. But, give the government the right to make that distinction and pretty soon, everyone will be too stupid to have guns. That's how this game works, that's how it has always worked. Ensuring the freedom of the people means we need to accept that some subset of the people will have freedoms we might prefer they do not.

There are a lot of people too stupid to be allowed to vote, or speak freely, yet I will defend to death their right to do so. The same applies to all of our freedoms.

The slippery slope argument is only a fallacy if you're not already halfway down the slope. As it stands today, we have to ask permission to exercise our rights, wait some indeterminate period measured in months or years, then face potential felony charges for exercising that right in certain locations. That right can be stripped from us without due process from even the most baseless of accusations. This is what happens when we decide to allow the exclusion of certain groups from free exercise of their rights. There's a reason it says "shall not be infringed"... our forefathers saw this game being played over 200 years ago.

Holland · Saturday at 2:48 PM

Pocket holster might've been a good idea

Saltwater60 · Saturday at 3:20 PM

Holland said:
Pocket holster might've been a good idea

Never have a gun anywhere on your person not in a holster that covers the trigger adequately

RedBreast21 · Saturday at 5:13 PM

Well this is NY so SCOTUS opinions and rulings are optional for LEO and Govt. If it went down and written, a sign is a request at best and any good lawyer will get this man out of it but the cost to him is the victory for the State and a lesson to us all. :beer:

Robin · 2025-08-31T05:46:35-0400

I some states the reaction would be "excuse me sir, you dropped this".
In others,

Robin

spat · 2025-08-31T06:06:31-0400

Saltwater60 said:
Dang shame. Don’t know him but clearly not criminal of the year but now he is. I hope it goes to a jury trial and the jury takes matters into their own hands. I’d find him not guilty of criminal possession of a weapon. He has a permit.

I'd find him not guilty whether he has a permit or not.

spat · 2025-08-31T06:08:28-0400

RedBreast21 said:
Well this is NY so SCOTUS opinions and ruling are optional. If it went down and written, a sign is a request at best and any good lawyer will get this man out of it but the cost to him the victory for the State and a lesson to us all.

The process is the punishment.

That's why anyone who isn't convicted of every charge they are indicted for should be compensated for their time dealing with every acquittal or plea bargain.

spat · 2025-08-31T06:11:04-0400

Beerman said:
And maybe, just maybe, some of *those* people shouldn’t have guns, either.

Who would you trust to decide ?

If you can't trust someone with a gun, then they can't be trusted to walk free. It's that simple.

Brawny71 · 2025-08-31T08:14:46-0400

I thought signs and gun free zones (not listed in the prohibited areas in the questionable NYS law) were found unconstitutional and unenforceable.

Beerman · 2025-08-31T10:04:28-0400

spat said:
Who would you trust to decide ?

If you can't trust someone with a gun, then they can't be trusted to walk free. It's that simple.

I guess you answered your own question. :beer:

If you want *my* opinion of an example of someone who I would not trust with a gun, I would cite those deemed mentally incompetent or unstable as untrustworthy with a gun.

Zerex · 2025-08-31T10:34:51-0400

He will either lose his permit or have it suspended for some time.
Insecure carry, kills the gun owner every time.

The Boonville Fair, is a a well known place where danger lurks around every corner...............oops, I was thinking about the NYS Fair!!

spat · 2025-08-31T11:55:14-0400

Beerman said:
I guess you answered your own question.

If you want *my* opinion of an example of someone who I would not trust with a gun, I would cite those deemed mentally incompetent or unstable as untrustworthy with a gun.

So, only a jury of your peers gets to decide, and only after all due process for a criminal conviction.

That's about the only thing I would accept.

And even then, only for the duration of your incarceration.

OwnTheRide · 2025-08-31T12:18:16-0400

Beerman said:
I guess you answered your own question.

If you want *my* opinion of an example of someone who I would not trust with a gun, I would cite those deemed mentally incompetent or unstable as untrustworthy with a gun.

Remember when our governor declared that we were "extremists?"

Many on the left consider our interest in firearms to be a mental illness in itself.

Again, agree to exclude certain groups and the other side will seek to expand that group to include you.

RooftopKorean · 2025-08-31T12:26:41-0400

Great Job NY! Another dangerous criminal nabbed.

Saltwater60 · 2025-08-31T21:36:27-0400

RooftopKorean said:
Great Job NY! Another dangerous criminal nabbed.

If he was a dangerous criminal he’d be let out of jail faster.

Bustedknees · 2025-08-31T21:41:53-0400

The people that ignore any and all gun laws in Boonville is most likely over 90%.

Darth · 2025-08-31T22:30:07-0400

The victim count in this scenario has climbed all the way to 0.

Brawny71 · 2025-09-01T07:57:55-0400

Saltwater60 said:
If he was a dangerous criminal he’d be let out of jail faster.

….with a Visa card and new iPhone.

Brawny71 · 2025-09-01T08:10:01-0400

OwnTheRide said:
Remember when our governor declared that we were "extremists?"

Many on the left consider our interest in firearms to be a mental illness in itself.

Again, agree to exclude certain groups and the other side will seek to expand that group to include you.

Me dressing with a gun because it makes me comfortable is a mental disease (which NOONE ELSE is aware of)? But if I put on a dress and woman’s underwear I’m “brave”. “Things that scare the hell out of me in state legislature for $800 please.”

Zerex · 2025-09-01T09:52:17-0400

Case will likely not go further than the PP office.............it will suspend, and local JP will say "case closed". No Jury will ever rule on the 2nd Amendment. Sensitive Areas case was ruled on already.

Defilade · 2025-09-01T10:04:41-0400

Sensitive areas..LOL.. Looks like we have Kings and Queens who have drawn those lines..

Handgun falls out of man's pocket while he's on ride at Boonville-Oneida County Fair

.450/400 Nitro Ex

.308 Win

.450/400 Nitro Ex

20×102mm Vulcan

6.5 Creedmoor

.450/400 Nitro Ex

9mm

6.5 Creedmoor

.223 Rem

9mm

20×102mm Vulcan

.450/400 Nitro Ex

6.5 Creedmoor

.577 Tyrannosaur.

.700 Nitro Express

.700 Nitro Express

.700 Nitro Express

.357 mag

6.5 Creedmoor

.308 Win

.700 Nitro Express

.223 Rem

6.5 Creedmoor

20×102mm Vulcan

.308 Win

Bunny In Chief

.357 mag

.357 mag

.308 Win

.700 Nitro Express