Jaywmustang
.308 Win
10mm
357 revolver or 9mm conceal carry pistol. Which to buy?
- Thread starter Target
- Start date
meketrefe
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Evolution of firearms
Every time a substantial design change was introduced and established, it was
for very good reasons and why, today, in law enforcement, military, special units, serious
personal defense, etc... revolvers are not issued anymore.
Effectiveness aside, one might like something based on historic or sentimental value.
First...
Then...
Then...
Then ...
And Finally...
We should not justify buying a honda SUV to go deep into the jungle and expect to make it out.
We might make it out but most folks who want to have a chance to make it out will go for
a properly offroad fitted Toyota 4runner or landcruiser or something like that.
So we have to be very pragmatic and realistic with our needs and expectations.
Is it a defensive firearm what you really want?
Every time a substantial design change was introduced and established, it was
for very good reasons and why, today, in law enforcement, military, special units, serious
personal defense, etc... revolvers are not issued anymore.
Effectiveness aside, one might like something based on historic or sentimental value.
First...
Then...
Then...
Then ...
And Finally...
We should not justify buying a honda SUV to go deep into the jungle and expect to make it out.
We might make it out but most folks who want to have a chance to make it out will go for
a properly offroad fitted Toyota 4runner or landcruiser or something like that.
So we have to be very pragmatic and realistic with our needs and expectations.
Is it a defensive firearm what you really want?
Yes he does, lest he wouldn't be able to own any pistols in NYS.
Did I mis-read post # 12?
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
He says, "I don't have a CC pistol, also do not have a full CC permit ( Sportsman restriction on it )."
I take that to mean that he doesn't have a concealed carry pistol and a full carry permit. His has a sportsman restriction on it.
Yes.
And he also wasn't clear.
He has a CCW with administrative restrictions. All permits in NYS (besides premises) are CCW permits.
Jaywmustang
.308 Win
U can only use your pistol for hunting and at the gun range but u can not carry it for self defense
meketrefe
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Oh!!
For hunting, an AR with a 10" barrel in 458 socom is simple and very effective hunter.
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
10-15 feet?? Sounds like you need much more practice behind that revolver. Try 38 +p+
Robin
.475 A&M Magnum
That means if the burgeler is armed you have to try and shoot the gun from his hand first.
Robin
GoodGuywitha9mm
.45 acp
2" Bbl. is luck beyond that distance...
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
Oh, well belly guns weren’t meant to be accurate beyond that distance.
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
I went today to inspect that revolver.
1-As I was warned, she is BIG. Much more so than a Rossi 357 they had on display.
2-Not all original. Had coating on cylinder and hammer. SN of cyl matches. Pachmyre grips.
3- It had minimal cylinder play in full lock, Overall good shape for a 55yr old piece. Some bluing worn at muzzle.
I will hold off for now. Were it all blued, I'd have pro ably bought it.
1-As I was warned, she is BIG. Much more so than a Rossi 357 they had on display.
2-Not all original. Had coating on cylinder and hammer. SN of cyl matches. Pachmyre grips.
3- It had minimal cylinder play in full lock, Overall good shape for a 55yr old piece. Some bluing worn at muzzle.
I will hold off for now. Were it all blued, I'd have pro ably bought it.
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
The trigger on that is no big deal. It’s nothing more that a removable trigger shoe that somebody put on there. It’s only held on by set screws. Did I read that correctly? The S/N on the Cylinder matched the S/N on the frame? The S series S/N’s are collectable firearms.
Last edited:
Why was my quote from another thread out here? @NYGuns
kev74
20×102mm Vulcan
...Until you paint /ceracoat them. D'oh!
There are better examples to be had for that price.
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
SN dates it to 1958/59. Barrel is stamped Highway Patrol . After the 1st year, they're stamped Model 28.
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
Removed
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
Yeah, a bubba job for sure. I can’t tell for certain from just the one pic but it also looks as though they did their own version of a chamfered cylinder. If so that’s a damn shame. Ceracoating the cylinder was bad enough....Until you paint /ceracoat them. D'oh!
There are better examples to be had for that price.
Last edited:
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
Not sure if this helps.
I carry a .38+p SW 442 on a regular basis and I love the gun. I would recommend you take a look at one of those. I personally wouldn’t want a .357mag in a snub nose. But I do have a ruger GP100 in .357 mag 4inch that I am waiting on new grips compacts from Altamont so I can put my GP in carry rotation when I just want to carry the big boy and when I’m hunting.
I also have a springfield xds 4 inch 9mm. I carry this often as well and would recommend. I am in the 9mm and .38+p camp for ccw.
I also have a springfield xds 4 inch 9mm. I carry this often as well and would recommend. I am in the 9mm and .38+p camp for ccw.
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
Well, I hope you boys are right. I placed and order tonight.
Walther PPS M2 9mm Pistol, Black - 2805961
I went to Gander to handle both the Shield and the PPS ( both were priced at $407 plus tax).
All the online reading I've done state that the PPS is a great gun, so took a leap of faith and went for it.
I really wanted to see a Mossberg MC1 but they're sold out everywhere.
My first handgun on my carry permit was a stainless Ruger SP101 .357 w 2" barrel. It is dimensionally identical to a Smith Model 60 in .357, and easier to find. It is still near and dear to my heart and I take it out to carry with regularity. I love the look and feel of revolvers, and my preference is for stainless versions. It conceals fine in an OWB holster.
My other main carry guns are M&P Shields, - both the 9mm and the .45. Normally by pocket carry.
My other main carry guns are M&P Shields, - both the 9mm and the .45. Normally by pocket carry.