Doc8404
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Yeah, there's no one around and you are leaving it.
Legal with pistol? Long arm?
Legal with pistol? Long arm?
Deer meets car. Can you shoot it?
- Thread starter Doc8404
- Start date
Lol.I was just thinking about this on the way home from work tonight.I would think its not legal.unless its during hunting season,during shooting hours,and off the road(other side of the ditch).also 500 feet from structure,unless you have permission from the owner.guess circumstances would dictate if its legal or not.
spat
.700 Nitro Express
Can you back over it ?
Acer-m14
20×102mm Vulcan
best to just wait for the officer then ask .. i can save you some paper work if you want me to dispatch it ..
Doc8404
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Great idea. response times can suck. If the officer shows up, i won't need to do it.
MikeyCNY
6.5 Creedmoor
Seems like you could get charged for discharging a firearm near a road..
timboy
.44 mag
Though I feel it is the humane thing to do I doubt it would be a good idea in these days.
Then again..
Then again..
Catskillkid
.450/400 Nitro Ex
I guy I knew said he kept a knife handy in the glove box to open up an artery in case that happened. Only hit one deer myself and it died pretty quick.
Also heard a story about a guy who hit a deer with his car. Deer was laying on the side of the road still alive. Another driver pulled up behind him got out and told the guy who hit the deer that he had a shotgun in the trunk of his car and would dispatch the deer (I think he wanted to take it home with him to process). Anyway, Guy #2 gets his shotgun, pumps the action, deer's eyes open up, hops up and runs off before a shot can fired. I guess it had heard that sound before.
Also heard a story about a guy who hit a deer with his car. Deer was laying on the side of the road still alive. Another driver pulled up behind him got out and told the guy who hit the deer that he had a shotgun in the trunk of his car and would dispatch the deer (I think he wanted to take it home with him to process). Anyway, Guy #2 gets his shotgun, pumps the action, deer's eyes open up, hops up and runs off before a shot can fired. I guess it had heard that sound before.
I agree with the knife to cut its throat. Unless the deer is still spry, then shoot it.
I know around here 99.9% of police and wildlife officers will allow you to dispatch the deer and take it home. We are very rural and hunting is inbedded in our culture. Nobody wants an animal to go to waste.
I know around here 99.9% of police and wildlife officers will allow you to dispatch the deer and take it home. We are very rural and hunting is inbedded in our culture. Nobody wants an animal to go to waste.
Except the jpd.or Lakewood busti.actually,I wouldn't trust the troopers in chautauqua either
Saltwater60
.950 JDJ
I agree with this. What if the deer gets up and runs back into the road? Could be dangerous. I think you could make a case for it. If you can wait I sure would, but you can't always. I have thought about this many times as well.
We deal almost exclusively with the sheriffs.
Ive never had any issues with any of them though.
C3D
.338 Win Mag
There's a calculus to be done here to shoot the deer.
Limb one: pain and suffering in a wounded animal, vs
Limb two: euthanizing the animal, and taking a risk that you will have the wrong officer respond/the wrong DA and be prosecuted for any number of different charges, which can result in losing your job, your ability to provide for your family, and possibly jail time.
It's a tough call; I keep a knife in my car as others have stated, I would handle it that way.
Limb one: pain and suffering in a wounded animal, vs
Limb two: euthanizing the animal, and taking a risk that you will have the wrong officer respond/the wrong DA and be prosecuted for any number of different charges, which can result in losing your job, your ability to provide for your family, and possibly jail time.
It's a tough call; I keep a knife in my car as others have stated, I would handle it that way.
Yep sheriffs ellicott and the frewsburger cops are all good.IV never had a problem with any either,but I don't want to test it.damn,I posted that earlier but got crap reception from my stand
Gdammit!I'm done posting from treestands!just deleted 3 or 4 repeat posts.and I'm in another stand
JPD are a bunch of young hotheads now. I rarely go anywhere near JT.
I live out by the PA border near Corry PA kinda. No JPD out here.
FRANKIE
.308 Win
I am not even a hunter.
Dispatch and leave. Legal gun owners are humane.
Or, wait around for the possibility some passerby might just happen to have a euthanizing kit,
or the cop that comes does it himself. (just my take of course)
Dispatch and leave. Legal gun owners are humane.
Or, wait around for the possibility some passerby might just happen to have a euthanizing kit,
or the cop that comes does it himself. (just my take of course)
UpStateEd
.45 acp
I'd put a knife in the deer's hoof and say it was self defense.
I grew up in West Ellicott, right near Busti.
Bushmaster
.308 Win
phatfarmerbob
.223 Rem
Did this to a wounded raccoon once on a first date
Bushmaster
.308 Win
Had fun watching post. NO you can NOT shoot it legally....
Foxtrapper
.40 S&W
No, do not shoot it. A pissy DEC guy will say you shot it, and then ran it over. I actually picked one (deer) that was still alive and took it to the game warden's house and demanded he put it down, because he was unwilling to come to the sence and do it. Almost got a ticket for it, but he decieded that keeping his job was more important..