Frey VS nyc/nys

[libertysnake]

I always knew Amy was a recommended lawyer around these parts but wow this is amazing to see her fighting this. Definitely keeping her as one of the emergency contacts I've told friends and family to call if I'm ever arrested, because the first and only thing I'm telling police is "I'd like to speak to a lawyer."

 

[Phazer]

I always knew Amy was a recommended lawyer around these parts but wow this is amazing to see her fighting this. Definitely keeping her as one of the emergency contacts I've told friends and family to call if I'm ever arrested, because the first and only thing I'm telling police is "I'd like to speak to a lawyer."

She's on my "must call" list, too.

 

[Egret-II]

I have said before, if open carry is illegal in NYS, show me the sections of law which given an exemption for security guards and law enforcement to open carry.

FUKH didn't know about open carry. She is gonna make it illegal now.

 

[Jmac00]

I just read through the whole thing. Wow, they are definitely swinging for the fences with this filing. And, as a lifelong practitioner of the English language, to my reading they are factually correct in every assertion made.

Of course, as NYS and the larger judicial system are impossibly corrupt, the plaintiffs will be arrested, the judge will declare “No standing” and Hochul et al will trumpet that another dangerous challenge to their little fiefdom has been squashed and the serfs have been reminded of their place in society, namely on the bottom of their supposed master’s shoe.

unless 10,000 OPENLY ARMED citizens show up with them. Then whorchuls little kingdom will have a huge problem on their hands

 

[Saltwater60]

History, Text and Tradition, Open Carry is the true Constitutional protected 2A right..

You do t have to convince me, but the queen thinks she can do as she pleases and so far it’s worked. She will pull some bullshit emergency order out of her ass and put us all on lockdown for guns and bypass any law. She will not be deterred.

 

[Saltwater60]

She's on my "must call" list, too.

She’s on my mustang call list of I get fucked as well as a good criminal defense attorney. I hope to never have to make that call.

 

[That_FNG]

You do t have to convince me, but the queen thinks she can do as she pleases and so far it’s worked. She will pull some bullshit emergency order out of her ass and put us all on lockdown for guns and bypass any law. She will not be deterred.

The greater the arrogance and hubris of man the harder they fall. Even the mighty Roman empire falls.

 

[spat]

A well respected local law firm.

Legal Representation – Advocacy - Attorney

Bellantoni Law offers legal representation and advocacy to clients who seek to protect their civil rights. Our attorneys are qualified and extend advocacy support whenever you need it. With more than 15 years of legal experience we provide comprehensive and personal attention to all clients...

www.bellantoni-law.com

Maybe skip the fundraising organizations and send a check right to the law firm payable to the Freys themselves.

That way there can be no shenanigans about frozen funds.

 

[Saltwater60]

The greater the arrogance and hubris of man the harder they fall. Even the mighty Roman empire falls.

Oh I’d love to see her cry on national TV. It would be great to see her melt down. Her arrogance will make her hit the ground so hard newton will have to go back and rewrite the laws of physics.

 

[Carlos Hathcock]

unless 10,000 OPENLY ARMED citizens show up with them. Then whorchuls little kingdom will have a huge problem on their hands

Time & place please

 

[Egret-II]

Why is it that no reporter asked her point blank "if guns are so bad. And nobody needs a gun in NYC or NYS. Why is it that you have a security detail with glocks and AR15? Isn't that some hypocrisy?. Guns for me but not for thee"

 

[Jsmegs77]

Maybe skip the fundraising organizations and send a check right to the law firm payable to the Freys themselves.

That way there can be no shenanigans about frozen funds.

This is quite probably the best option. Fundraising sites, no matter which ones, are a tall poppy and will be the first to see the lawnmower blade. Sending contributions directly to the attorneys referencing the case has got to be a little more vandal-proof, unless said legal firm has a shitweasel in their employ.

 

[maverick52]

Wow. Amy Bellatoni. I know she’s a well respected 2A lawyer in Westchester. Glad to see she’s going for the jugular.

 

[spat]

This is quite probably the best option. Fundraising sites, no matter which ones, are a tall poppy and will be the first to see the lawnmower blade. Sending contributions directly to the attorneys referencing the case has got to be a little more vandal-proof, unless said legal firm has a shitweasel in their employ.

Yea, and the fundraising sites will roll over for the state with not so much as a pretty please if requested to freeze the funds.

I can imagine even most left wing lawyers getting a bit nervous if the state tries to order lawyers to turn over their clients retainers....

 

[Acer-m14]

If the plaintiffs are arrested, we'll get faces and names attached to this un-American statute as they get to exercise their right to a speedy trial.

If they are not arrested, they will prove that either concealed-is-concealed or the emperor has no clothes.

well NYC lets this open carry go on .. its the catch them if you can .... and release them ASAP BS ..

 

[camper4lyfe]

Can someone interpret this? The judge dismissed the case back in September, but it's still going (not that I'm complaining)?

Frey et al v. Bruen et al (7:21-cv-05334), New York Southern District Court

Frey et al v. Bruen et al (7:21-cv-05334), New York Southern District Court, Filed: 06/16/2021

www.pacermonitor.com

 

[Phazer]

Reading up on the Frey case, it doesn't look too promising.

Frey et al v. Bruen et al (7:21-cv-05334), New York Southern District Court

This seems important.

It appears that this case is having a lot of difficulty getting into court.

 

[FP1201]

unless 10,000 OPENLY ARMED citizens show up with them. Then whorchuls little kingdom will have a huge problem on their hands

i had thought the same thing when we rallied against the SAFE act.
Honestly, I'd always been told "outside carry was illegal in NY" and accepted it as such...
There doesn't seem to be any issue with Handgun Hunting (outside carry) or obviously carrying a long gun, but I suspect the po-po would come blazing in with lights, sirens, and guns drawn if someone were walking down the Street carrying a Gun, which sounds counterintuitive to walking down that same street with a gun in a case/sock/scabbard or bringing it into a Business such as a Gun Shop or someplace that sells/repairs guns.

 

[Aether]

The case was dismissed “without prejudice” on 9/1. “Without prejudice” means that the plaintiffs may file an amended case by a set date (10/3). If this is done, the judge will treat the amended filing as a new case. The plaintiffs did file an amended case on 10/3.

The judge reviewed the amended filing and on 10/4. The judge found deficiencies in the filing and directed Bellatoni, et al to correct the deficiencies with specific instructions on how to do so. Bellatoni, et al filed the corrected amended complaint later in the day on 10/4.

IMHO, the judge is bending over backward to give the plaintiffs a fair hearing. 2A cases are political bombshells right now and no judge wants to be overruled due to procedural errors. This is a good indicator AFAIK.

 

[Egret-II]

Any update on this lawsuit?