NYS Compliant AR-15

J

James R

.177 BB
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Location
Upstate New York
Hi, I am new to this forum and have been searching everywhere for answers, I am looking to make a NYS legal and compliant ar-15 it has a threaded barrel with muzzle brake, pistol grip, and telescopic stock. Would a doing undetachable mag using a cross army safe mag solve all of my problems or would the threaded barrel still be illegal. If an undetachable mag won’t work with the threaded barrel I was thinking about going “bolt action” I have an adjustable gas block as well, if I cut of the gas supply with the adjustable gas block is that enough or do I need to remove the gas tube. If it is bolt action and has a detachable mag can I have all of the “evils” and my threaded barreled would I need both.
 
Last edited:
Jem45472

Jem45472

.308 Win
Messages
4,136
Reaction score
6,651
Location
Erie
With a fixed mag, you don't need to worry about anything else as long as barrel is 16" or better.

Not a very good time to be building.
 
Drinkthekoolaid

Drinkthekoolaid

.475 A&M Magnum
U.S. Military
Messages
14,707
Reaction score
25,472
Location
Unfortunately, NY
James R said:
If I fix the mag I can have a threaded barrel even tho it is still semi automatic?
Click to expand...


As best as we have been able to determine this horribly ambiguous law, is you have 2 choices

1- if you want removable mags you need a completely features rifle. Nothing on it. Not even a bayonet lug. Nothing.

2- go with a fixed mag.
 
libertysnake

libertysnake

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,225
Reaction score
15,108
Location
New York
It's not pretty, but if you want a detachable mag a spur grip works on just about anything. AKs w/Adapter, ARs, and fits closest to the letter of the law by reducing how much "protrusion" and preventing a full "pistol" style grasp, while lining up fairly close with the action of the rifle. Since NYS hasn't really defined what is or isn't a pistol style grasp, honestly it's anyone's guess as to what is or isn't compliant.

I'll be honest, it's a garbage grip -- but it works and it's cheap. I think, and I could be wrong, the spur has been involved in cases where a crime was committed as well. I believe the Bronx hospital shooter a while back, had one on an AR. The police afaik didn't charge the shooter with assault weapons charges on top of the murder ones, presumably because they found the spur compliant with the spur? I don't know the full case details, so don't take my word on that.


If anyone knows more details about spur cases, by all means contribute.
 
BDinPutnam

BDinPutnam

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
14,492
Reaction score
20,850
Location
Someplace else
Drinkthekoolaid said:
As best as we have been able to determine this horribly ambiguous law, is you have 2 choices

1- if you want removable mags you need a completely features rifle. Nothing on it. Not even a bayonet lug. Nothing.

2- go with a fixed mag.
Click to expand...

My two cents- #1 above is the more practical of the two but more importantly perhaps- it is the less ambiguous of the two.
 
Figment

Figment

9mm
Messages
91
Reaction score
154
Location
Western NY
Drinkthekooldaid has it expressed best, with a fixed mag it's no longer a "detachable mag" and you can have all the features you want, or you'd have to change just about everything to make it a compliant rifle and have a detachable mag. But, we're not lawyers, and we're not the LEO that still might charge you out of ignorance of the law. So good luck, everyone is taking a risk no matter what with this really bad law. Search is your friend here on what is the best option for "fixed mag". There is a lot of grey and that is terrible for people that are literally trying to do the right thing to comply with the law and not get tied up in a court charge.
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

.950 JDJ
Messages
31,350
Reaction score
35,067
Location
Western NY
I agree fix the mag but do not use the one you mention in your original post as that one is not a fixed mag and as you close the action it’s a fully functional firearm and you insert a magazine. Therefore that type of set up allows a fully assembled and functional firearm to accept a detachable magazine making it illegal. This is the system I wanted until some one pointed this out to me. At first I thought they were nuts and splitting hair but if you think about it it actually makes sense.
Get the DD’s ranch fixed mag button.
 
GOYABEAN

GOYABEAN

.950 JDJ
Messages
32,326
Reaction score
67,068
Location
Land of Freedom PA
Drinkthekoolaid said:
As best as we have been able to determine this horribly ambiguous law, is you have 2 choices

1- if you want removable mags you need a completely features rifle. Nothing on it. Not even a bayonet lug. Nothing.

2- go with a fixed mag.
Click to expand...

3 - Escape the :fuac: land gulag and build balls wild to your hearts content :headbang:
 
I

ICEMAN

.40 S&W
Messages
138
Reaction score
131
Location
WNY
I would still prefer featureless vs fixed mag. There are plenty of work arounds to reload through ejection port and different ways to pull back pin if you go fixed mag. I would just want my rifle to function as designed and clear malfunctions, if needed,the way I was trained to.
 
cgrutt

cgrutt

.338 Win Mag
NYGF Vendor
Monthly Donor
Messages
8,877
Reaction score
16,721
Location
Interwebz
libertysnake said:
It's not pretty, but if you want a detachable mag a spur grip works on just about anything. AKs w/Adapter, ARs, and fits closest to the letter of the law by reducing how much "protrusion" and preventing a full "pistol" style grasp, while lining up fairly close with the action of the rifle. Since NYS hasn't really defined what is or isn't a pistol style grasp, honestly it's anyone's guess as to what is or isn't compliant.

I'll be honest, it's a garbage grip -- but it works and it's cheap. I think, and I could be wrong, the spur has been involved in cases where a crime was committed as well. I believe the Bronx hospital shooter a while back, had one on an AR. The police afaik didn't charge the shooter with assault weapons charges on top of the murder ones, presumably because they found the spur compliant with the spur? I don't know the full case details, so don't take my word on that.


If anyone knows more details about spur cases, by all means contribute.
Click to expand...
Spur grip and no other features...
 
J

James R

.177 BB
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Location
Upstate New York
I’ve heard that even with a fixed mag, it is still a semi automatic rifle therefore cannot have a threaded barrel. is that true. I know that bolt action rifle can have a threaded barrel
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

.950 JDJ
Messages
34,640
Reaction score
36,482
Location
Livingston
buy a mini or a mosin less of a NY headache and don't forget the Russian stripers .. the Chinese ones suck
 
J

James R

.177 BB
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Location
Upstate New York
Figment said:
Drinkthekooldaid has it expressed best, with a fixed mag it's no longer a "detachable mag" and you can have all the features you want, or you'd have to change just about everything to make it a compliant rifle and have a detachable mag. But, we're not lawyers, and we're not the LEO that still might charge you out of ignorance of the law. So good luck, everyone is taking a risk no matter what with this really bad law. Search is your friend here on what is the best option for "fixed mag". There is a lot of grey and that is terrible for people that are literally trying to do the right thing to comply with the law and not get tied up in a court charge.
Click to expand...
I’ve heard that even with a fixed mag, it is still a semi automatic rifle therefore cannot have a threaded barrel. is that true. I know that bolt action rifle can have a threaded barrel
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

.950 JDJ
Messages
34,640
Reaction score
36,482
Location
Livingston
James R said:
It was what cgrutt sent me. Article 265 Penal Law Firearms | Dangerous Weapons | NY Law
Click to expand...

what you highlighted is why i question .. the site name .. i triple check ..

but i do need a new book .. with updates .. one got yrs ago was a gift ..

511ugjKFEFL._AC_SY400_.jpg
 
J

James R

.177 BB
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Location
Upstate New York
Okay, I will definitely pin the clip tomorrow however now I just need to find out what clip to use. 10 round or a 5 round. The guy who made this has to be the most mentally challenged human in the world.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top