Honor Defense Honor Guard 9mm: A New Pistol You Won’t Want To Pass Up
- Thread starter Dr. Evil
- Start date
I've heard that these are Shield clones. Looking at the pics one can certainly see a strong resemblance. If the quality is there this is no bad thing and the grip stippling and forward slide sereations stand out as worthwhile improvements.
Just checked the prices and they are more than The Shield. That being the case I see little point to the thing. Usually when a manufacturer produces a clone of a successful design it is with the purpose offering it a lower price.
Just checked the prices and they are more than The Shield. That being the case I see little point to the thing. Usually when a manufacturer produces a clone of a successful design it is with the purpose offering it a lower price.
Last edited:
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
When I'm in the market for a CC pistol, I'd buy one of these. I handled one at the Syr gun show last spring and liked it.
They are not common and the one the vendor had ( only one at the show) was a "Stand Off" model where the trigger frame extends 1" beyond the barrel.
Kinda odd looking and I think I'd get the normal one for CC. It would seem the stand off would snag on something while drawn.
The biggest complaint that I've read online is that most do not like the heavy use of company logo on pretty much every flat surface.
They had trigger issues on the first batch that has been corrected.
Dad always said, never buy anything the first year they're out.
Davidson's is having a sale on the version with a "Stand off" . Pretty much same price as normal one ($450ish) but you get an extra 7rd magazine.
www.galleryofguns.com - Gun Genie - Davidson's most popular and powerful search engine to find and buy guns at galleryofguns.com
They are not common and the one the vendor had ( only one at the show) was a "Stand Off" model where the trigger frame extends 1" beyond the barrel.
Kinda odd looking and I think I'd get the normal one for CC. It would seem the stand off would snag on something while drawn.
The biggest complaint that I've read online is that most do not like the heavy use of company logo on pretty much every flat surface.
They had trigger issues on the first batch that has been corrected.
Dad always said, never buy anything the first year they're out.
Davidson's is having a sale on the version with a "Stand off" . Pretty much same price as normal one ($450ish) but you get an extra 7rd magazine.
www.galleryofguns.com - Gun Genie - Davidson's most popular and powerful search engine to find and buy guns at galleryofguns.com
Saltwater60
.950 JDJ
I looked at them and passed pretty quickly on it. They are intriguing, but I don't like the sheiks grip and I did not like this grip either because they are the same gun. Also when I looked there were very few options for night sights and stuff. I liked there statement though. They hire a lot of vets.
Saltwater60
.950 JDJ
Niagara gun range in north tonawanda ny has them. I know it's a drive for you in central ny, but wanted to let other know.
MikeyCNY
6.5 Creedmoor
I know @wizrd is interested in this. Good price. One of the few complaints I've read is they only have a 2 or 3 year warranty; in the world of firearms that's kind of short. Maybe it's one of those 'call us after 3 years and we'll see what we can do' warranties. Even SCCY had to update their warranty recently because there were people abusing the "lost/stolen" part of the warranty.
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
I just got back from my local box store ( Runnings) and was able to fondle both a Shield and a Honor Guard (suprised they had one.).
Very similar.
Honor Guard has a slightly wider slide, more aggressive stippling and a couple other features not found on the Shield.
I prefered the HG sights and they're Glock compatible if I choose to change in the future.
Either would work for me. Mags are easily found for the M&P, not so much for the other one.
$10 less for the HG . One was $439. Shoulda taken notes.
Very similar.
Honor Guard has a slightly wider slide, more aggressive stippling and a couple other features not found on the Shield.
I prefered the HG sights and they're Glock compatible if I choose to change in the future.
Either would work for me. Mags are easily found for the M&P, not so much for the other one.
$10 less for the HG . One was $439. Shoulda taken notes.
MikeyCNY
6.5 Creedmoor
How were the triggers? I upgraded the trigger on my Shield.
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
Both had trigger locks on 'em. Didn't ask to have them removed.
Phazer
.450/400 Nitro Ex
I'd like to try it. I've got a decent selection of single-stack 9mm defensive pistols. But, I don't have a Shield...yet.
I like the grip stippling (at least, by the look of it):
I like the grip stippling (at least, by the look of it):
No mention of trigger pull weight, performance/accuracy? Looks ok, but wonder what it's internals are based upon? What is it offering me other than different cosmetics and ambidextrous function for mag release, which coincidently, I don't particularly care for. Make left/right pistols... ; )
As mentioned, there's not a chance I'd carry one until performance is proven. Just me, but I'd like to know its gonna work if heaven forbid I ever needed it. My $.02...
As mentioned, there's not a chance I'd carry one until performance is proven. Just me, but I'd like to know its gonna work if heaven forbid I ever needed it. My $.02...
What don't you like about the Shield's grip.
Target
6.5 Creedmoor
Helps prevent the slide from being pushed out of battery if you jam the muzzle into soft tissue of an assailant.
I believe that there was a recent situation where an officer was not able to shoot due to this.
Can't find the reference to see if the officer was killed or not.
I believe that there was a recent situation where an officer was not able to shoot due to this.
Can't find the reference to see if the officer was killed or not.
Uzi
.308 Win
The grip texture looks effective, but man, that thing is ugly as hell. Doesn't look too thin either. I don't like it.
Saltwater60
.950 JDJ
It's just to thin for me. I like the feel of the double stacks way better. My hand just feels empty with the single stacks. I also shoot better with the double stacks. My support hand pad is in better contact with the left side of the grip. I feel the gun moves less on me and I hit the target more center than low and left.
Fair enough. Single stack sub compacts certainly have drawbacks. I live the way the Shield disappears in belt though.
wizrd
6.5 Creedmoor
Haven't had my hands on one of these yet -- but asking about them on a few other forums, everyone who has one seems to really like them. Several guys remarked that it has become their favorite EDC. One guy said he has 4 Shields that just sit in his safe now. I figure that this 9mm cartridge may be around for a while - may just finally buy one.
ECU Pirates
.308 Win
I have a shield and really like it. That being said I don't know why someone Would buy four of them!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
MikeyCNY
6.5 Creedmoor
Primary, a backup, a secondary backup, a tertiary backup.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
That's the same with me. With the single stack XDS, my shots were low and to the left. I googled why and someone on another forum said that the grip was probably too thin.
He posted that if you take something skinny like a broom handle and squeeze it with your right hand, the top of the broom handle nose dives down and to the left.
Now if you take a fatter stick and squeeze it, the top moves a lot less because it fills your hand more.
That extra space in a single stack will cause you to squeeze harder. With the double stack, it fills your hand more so less pressure is used.
I tried it and it makes sense. I got a Glock 26 and low and behold, my shots were more to the center.
That's the same with me. With the single stack XDS, my shots were low and to the left. I googled why and someone on another forum said that the grip was probably too thin.
He posted that if you take something skinny like a broom handle and squeeze it with your right hand, the top of the broom handle nose dives down and to the left.
Now if you take a fatter stick and squeeze it, the top moves a lot less because it fills your hand more.
That extra space in a single stack will cause you to squeeze harder. With the double stack, it fills your hand more so less pressure is used.
I tried it and it makes sense. I got a Glock 26 and low and behold, my shots were more to the center.
Well if your grip made all the difference, wait until you get a HK P30sk.... Hint Hint.
