Haunt
.40 S&W
They are identical in size and a magnum DOES fit into the LR cylinder. The only difference is that the mag does not have the notches cut into it.
Rough Rider at Gander
- Thread starter Day444
- Start date
4excal
.338 Win Mag
Exactly. That's why I bought the Chiappa 10 shot 1873 pistola. For 179$ one of my funnest plinkers.
4excal
.338 Win Mag
Not one poke on the 1873. I have the 6 and the 10 shooter Chiappa and you have to poke it 6 or 10 times. Now my S & W model 60 is one poke and all 5 come out but not the C. 1873s. But I guess thats where the ole "you get what you pay for" theory comes in to play.
Last edited:
4excal
.338 Win Mag
It was fresh out of the manufacturing plant when I bought it 1873 sonny boooy. Back then I waited 2 years for them to make it..and you whippersnappers complain about waiting 4 weeks
ME NO SPEEKIE DA ENGLISHIt was fresh out of the manufacturing plant when I bought it 1873 sonny boooy. Back then I waited 2 years for them to make it..and you whippersnappers complain about waiting 4 weeks
DO U UNDERTAND
4excal
.338 Win Mag
ME TO OLD TO UNDERSTAND SPEEKIEN ENGLISKON
Bananabandit
.338 Win Mag
Hows Gander doing? Cant handle the rough riders?
Bananabandit
.338 Win Mag
Since its out on the table...why does chocolate milk come from brown cows?
4excal
.338 Win Mag
Your mother asked me why her son kept pestering her, while a Ron Jeremy-esque STALLION (her words, not mine) was around.Actually...nobody asked you any questions
Day444
.223 Rem
Well, the .22 magnum cylinder has finally arrived! No email before hand saying it was shipped. They say there would be?
Yes, the cylinders are different. Other than the magnum cylinder not being fluted and bearing a stamped marking that it is .22 Mag. The .22 mag is slightly smaller in diameter then .22 LR rounds. While the .22 mag will fit in a .22 LR, it's not true the other way around. Magnum rounds should be fired in a weapon designed for them! Rifles chambered for .22lr will have .22 mag. rounds cause a number of problems.
Yes, the cylinders are different. Other than the magnum cylinder not being fluted and bearing a stamped marking that it is .22 Mag. The .22 mag is slightly smaller in diameter then .22 LR rounds. While the .22 mag will fit in a .22 LR, it's not true the other way around. Magnum rounds should be fired in a weapon designed for them! Rifles chambered for .22lr will have .22 mag. rounds cause a number of problems.
Day444
.223 Rem
Apples to Oranges type comparison. Single action vs. double action. Isn't the md. 60 a .357?
4excal
.338 Win Mag
All I'm talking about is what you have to do to discard the spent casings. The description was completely Apple to Apple..nothing to do with single vs double action mechanics.
4excal
.338 Win Mag
And yea the model 60 is both. 357 and .38 and +P
Day444
.223 Rem
All I'm talking about is what you have to do to discard the spent casings. The description was completely Apple to Apple..nothing to do with single vs double action mechanics.
Does the cylinder of the Chiappa swing out? Are the spent shells ejected through a loading port? As the cylinder on the S+W swings out and the ejection rod pushes out all the spent shells. Not the same, except you're removing spent shells from a cylinder.
.22 vs .357/.38+p, yeah apple to apple cause they both go bang!
4excal
.338 Win Mag
Yes the Chiappa cylinder swings out, then you push the ejector rod through,manually turn once,push through,manually turn once, push through 8 more times
. My S & W was a 5 shot with a 5 headed ejector rod that you push once and all 5 casings get knocked out in one push.
Day444
.223 Rem
Still not making myself clear. The Chiappa is a single action pistol. The cylinder does not swing out via a crane. Where as on the Smith it stays in place via the crane. The Chiappa is loaded and unloaded one round at a time, only way to do it correctly! (Through the loading gate/port.)
ArmedCorgi
.475 A&M Magnum
I knew what you were saying.
Day444
.223 Rem
As a fellow Corgi person, I know you were smart enough to understand!
4excal
.338 Win Mag
ArmedCorgi
.475 A&M Magnum
Well there ya go, lol.Yeeeea I'm a cat person
Day444
.223 Rem
HA HA HA, LOL!
Snappo
6.5 Creedmoor
I have blown $100 at pizza joints with the family. This seems like a slam dunk no-brainer.
4excal
.338 Win Mag
Right? Me n my two children went to the dumbest movie on Saturday..could have bought this and couple boxes of ammunition
. It is what it is..a fun cheap plinker not to be over thought.
Day444
.223 Rem
Was a no brainer! Couldn't beat the price, decent reviews, cheap to shoot. Biggest snag with the whole transaction was waiting for Heritage to send the .22 Mag cylinder. Almost six weeks until it arrived, but the price was right. Go me a .22, .22 mag plinker for under $150.
Snappo
6.5 Creedmoor
Sadly Brownells wants $199 for the Heritage Rough Rider in 22 mag. Pfft. Since it's a rimfire; so we still have to go through the bullshit to get it added to our CCW? Ugh!
4excal
.338 Win Mag
Is that with both cylinders? You may be able to still find the Chiappa 1873 both cylinders for way under that. I got my 6 & 10 1873s from Buds, but that was a few years now..
Snappo
6.5 Creedmoor
Where is Bud's? I checked the Gander Mountain website but they are toast now due to the bankruptcy. The website is basically a holding spot. Locally I have Herb Philippsons, Second Amendment Arms, and Bare Arms. I should check and see if those smaller places have websites. Do I want both cylinders (22 LR and 22 Magnum) or just the 22 Magnum? I guess I want both, huh? I use a Marlin 870V for plinking with a rifle. I think I have a Leupold Rifleman or something lower level on it. Honestly it's dialed for 100 and I haven't even tried 200 with 22 LR. I figured it wouldn't reach that far.