Temporary Restaining Order Issued For Concealed Carry Improvement Act (merged thread)

[Truebeliever]

This has to be the dumbest thing I have ever heard of and is a way to take peoples guns and only that. If you did something wrong I get it but she didn’t. This is so vaguely and widely written that if I drive by a car pulled over on the thruway or an accident roadside I’m supposed to notify the pistol permit. What a joke.

Agreed, But this policy isn’t new. And note, it was the pistol section that did it. Not the cops at the scene .

 

[subsonic]

and now the state is going after the NRA again .. say goodbye to being a NRA firearms teacher now ..

the $400.00 16 hour class will now cost $1600

NY State Bill 2021-S9601

www.nysenate.gov

Thanks for including a link to the bill at least. No way I am watching through some clickbait YouTuber’s video complete with soy face in the thumbnail. Anyone still wondering why sperm counts have dropped by 50% in 50 years?

 

[US RIFLE M1A]

 

[Deplorable Me]

We live in a nation of elected Karens.

 

[ManualF150]

So does that mean one can drive to the store or diner with a valid pistol permit and CCW gun, for now, and not be a criminal?

 

[ROBBARTLEY]

So does that mean one can drive to the store or diner with a valid pistol permit and CCW gun, for now, and not be a criminal?

Yes

 

[FrankenCub]

So does that mean one can drive to the store or diner with a valid pistol permit and CCW gun, for now, and not be a criminal?

Except NYSP will still consider you a criminal seems their queen made her decree.

 

[ManualF150]

Yes

Oh, goody.

Someone should setup a poll to see how long this lasts. My bet it might hold up for 3 business days till they changed the laws again.

 

[ManualF150]

Except NYSP will still consider you a criminal seems their queen made her decree.

Yeah, isn't that the best part? How am I not surprised, lol.

 

[nortatoga]

Yes

 

[FrankenCub]

Oh, goody.

Someone should setup a poll to see how long this lasts. My bet it might hold up for 3 business days till they changed the laws again.

I think you're spot on. I only give it business days due to the weekend.
This has turned into a circle jerk to see who can get off faster.

 

[Deplorable Me]

NY Black Friday special:

All Civil Rights half off.

 

[dean3690]

For those who did not dig through Judge Sinatra's latest ruling on the CCIA, this is the money shot;

“In sum, the vast majority of land in New York is held privately, and it encompasses homes, stores, businesses, factories, vacant land, hotels, parking lots and garages, grocery stores, pharmacies, medical offices, hospitals, cemeteries, malls, sports and entertainment venues, and so on.

These are places that people exercising their rights, frequent every day when they move around outside their homes. The exclusion here makes all of these places presumptively off limits, backed up the by the threat of prison.

The Nation’s historical traditions have not countenanced such an incursion into the right to keep and bear arms across all varieties of private property spread across the land. The right to self-defense is no less important and no less recognized on private property.”

Judge John Sinatra (W.D.N.Y.) in Christian v. Nigrelli

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nywd.142551/gov.uscourts.nywd.142551.49.0.pdf

I am not a lawyer, but my favorite three words are 'and so on.'

As far as I am concerned, the CCIA is dead. Everything past this and Judge Suddaby's decision is the makup-up they put on a corpse for an open casket funeral.

which reminds me of the governors makeup

 

[Saltwater60]

I think you're spot on. I only give it business days due to the weekend.
This has turned into a circle jerk to see who can get off faster.

I agree as well. Mid week of next week is as long as I suspect this to last. It may even get tossed by end of day today.

 

[CaliberPlus]

If James had *any* integrity, she would be embarressed. I know, she doesn't, that was sarcasm.

 

[Uzi]

I AM NOT A LAWYER BUT.....

I don't need a judge for a fifth time to mention that the ccia law is unconstitutional. I didn't need to wait for a judge to say it even once either.

 

[Far king]

I am not a lawyer, but from what I hear in the lawyer and LE world, is that this law (CCIA) is now entirely unenforceable.

For a CCIA-based arrest to stick, this new ruling would have to be stayed, AND the state would have to have a perfect, 100% UNBROKEN success rate for the duration of FOUR (or more, if new cases arise) separate cases, all the way to AND including SCOTUS for a CCIA arrest case to stick.

All this takes into account that the CCIA has had NO positive ruling on the merits, the only luck it has had has been administrative.

If this new decision is stayed, and someone is subsequently arrested. at any moment any judge rules against the CCIA (and there are permanent injunction trials coming up that will likely end that way) the arrest will have to be dropped AND the arresting department will be subject to monumental lawsuits.

This is where the judge's wording of 'likely to succeed on the merits' come in. A warning not to enforce whether or not the temp injunction is stayed.

Again, I am not a lawyer.

If the arresting department is the state police will they too be subject to monumental lawsuits?

 

[Beerman]

Thanks for including a link to the bill at least. No way I am watching through some clickbait YouTuber’s video complete with soy face in the thumbnail. Anyone still wondering why sperm counts have dropped by 50% in 50 years?

Is it because balls were bigger back then? Is that why?

 

[livingston]

Paloma Capanna Esq. Talks about the state of these lawsuits. Starts around 35.20 This is almost a week behind .on this pod cast

2nd Amendment Show 11-21-22 | WYSL

Sean McKay Tim Hortons Chris Roc On Motorsports Paloma Capanna Esq.

wysl.podbean.com

 

[maverick52]

Paloma Capanna Esq. Talks about the state of these lawsuits. Starts around 35.20 This is almost a week behind .on this pod cast

2nd Amendment Show 11-21-22 | WYSL

Sean McKay Tim Hortons Chris Roc On Motorsports Paloma Capanna Esq.

wysl.podbean.com

Pretty much a summary of everything we know. I like what she said- this is going to be a long slough

 

[Deplorable Me]

With a little luck Hochul choked on a turkey bone.

 

[Jmac00]

Pretty much a summary of everything we know. I like what she said- this is going to be a long slough

She has been saying that since 2013 when the safe act was passed. here we are almost 10 years later, Hows that working out for you guys

 

[Jmac00]

With a little luck Hochul choked on a turkey bone.

Im thinking her throat is a lot stronger than you think. she may have swallowed a lot of dick to get where she is

 

[Acer-m14]

putting this here because she does bring up the CCIA and liberty baby has some choice words to say also ..

 

[maverick52]

She has been saying that since 2013 when the safe act was passed. here we are almost 10 years later, Hows that working out for you guys

She also said tbat Sinatras stay has already been stayed as it has been connected to Suddabys case.

 

[Saltwater60]

With a little luck Hochul choked on a turkey bone.

Better chance of Harris doing that or maybe not since she’s had so much more practice??

 

[Grimscale]

She also said tbat Sinatras stay has already been stayed as it has been connected to Suddabys case.

Curious.
People here are usually on top of that, and I haven't seen anything saying the two cases got linked.

 

[camper4lyfe]

Curious.
People here are usually on top of that, and I haven't seen anything saying the two cases got linked.

I agree. I wouldn't be surprised if that happened, but I find it strange that it hasn't been mentioned if it has happened. The timing of the rulings also makes me suspicious. The 2nd ruled on Suddaby before Sinatra made his ruling.

 

[maverick52]

I agree. I wouldn't be surprised if that happened, but I find it strange that it hasn't been mentioned if it has happened. The timing of the rulings also makes me suspicious. The 2nd ruled on Suddaby before Sinatra made his ruling.

I could be wrong. But I think that’s what Paloma said in the audio clip.

 

[FrankenCub]

This guy is basically laying it out that there's nothing we can do about CCIA.
Other than vote. We already know where that goes.