2A Attorney in Putnam County

A

Austin

.38 Special
Messages
45
Reaction score
6
Location
Putnam county
Hi everyone, what attorney would you recommend for getting your pistol permit in Putnam County and why? Thanks so much four help
 
A

Austin

.38 Special
Messages
45
Reaction score
6
Location
Putnam county
No felonies. I didn't get denied, I have my hearing in January. And I just think it may be possible I get denied and just wanted to go with an attorney to hopefully prevent that. The way I read the law I should be eligible, but its the up to the judges discretion.
 
carpediem

carpediem

.338 Win Mag
Messages
5,988
Reaction score
4,255
Location
Peoples' Republic of New York
I would lean toward the judge thinking that with 12 arrests, you are a habitual law breaker. 1, maybe 2 could be called "youthful indiscretion". 12? I am not a lawyer, but I wouldn't hold my breath. The way things are today, not a good climate for someone with that many arrests to try to get a concealed carry permit.
I may be proven wrong.
 
A

Austin

.38 Special
Messages
45
Reaction score
6
Location
Putnam county
They were 12plus years ago and most were violations. And it's not a concealed carry permit. I applied for a sportsman
 
C3D

C3D

.338 Win Mag
Messages
5,506
Reaction score
10,112
Location
Behind Enemy Lines
I think you will actually come across better without an attorney.

Be honest with the judge, sincerity counts. “Yes judge, I did a bit of stupid shit when I was younger. But I’ve matured and keep it clean.” Evidence to show a job, family, home ownership will all be helpful. If you have a clergyman who knows you and can vouch for your character, bring him. +1000 if you have small kids you can take in tow with you to court. Offer to take a drug test; the court probably won’t take you up on that. (But don’t do that if you will test positive . . . !)

An attorney doesn’t really have any legal expertise to bring here and a judge may resent it or feel you have something to hide. The only way you need an attorney is if the judge decides against you. Then get an attorney and file a motion to reargue or commence an Article 78 proceeding. Or, if you want to go for the full Monty, you can challenge by bring a 1983 case in Federal court.

Unfortunately notwithstanding the Heller and MacDonald cases, the current state of the law in New York is that a pistol license is a privilege and not a right. Don’t demand anything. Ask nicely.

And make sure to wear a suit, a tie, hide any tats, etc. Appearances count.
 
cgrutt

cgrutt

.338 Win Mag
NYGF Vendor
Monthly Donor
Messages
8,999
Reaction score
17,057
Location
Interwebz
Could get hung up with 4473 with prior record even if judge issues CCW just thinking outloud no experience with this. Good luck.
 
A

Austin

.38 Special
Messages
45
Reaction score
6
Location
Putnam county
C3D said:
I think you will actually come across better without an attorney.

Be honest with the judge, sincerity counts. “Yes judge, I did a bit of stupid shit when I was younger. But I’ve matured and keep it clean.” Evidence to show a job, family, home ownership will all be helpful. If you have a clergyman who knows you and can vouch for your character, bring him. +1000 if you have small kids you can take in tow with you to court. Offer to take a drug test; the court probably won’t take you up on that. (But don’t do that if you will test positive . . . !)

An attorney doesn’t really have any legal expertise to bring here and a judge may resent it or feel you have something to hide. The only way you need an attorney is if the judge decides against you. Then get an attorney and file a motion to reargue or commence an Article 78 proceeding. Or, if you want to go for the full Monty, you can challenge by bring a 1983 case in Federal court.

Unfortunately notwithstanding the Heller and MacDonald cases, the current state of the law in New York is that a pistol license is a privilege and not a right. Don’t demand anything. Ask nicely.

And make sure to wear a suit, a tie, hide any tats, etc. Appearances count.
Click to expand...
Ok thanks so much. What's you experience, no disrespect just curious.
Thanks again
 
BMF JK

BMF JK

.44 mag
Messages
842
Reaction score
1,916
Location
Genesee county
C3D said:
I think you will actually come across better without an attorney.

Be honest with the judge, sincerity counts. “Yes judge, I did a bit of stupid shit when I was younger. But I’ve matured and keep it clean.” Evidence to show a job, family, home ownership will all be helpful. If you have a clergyman who knows you and can vouch for your character, bring him. +1000 if you have small kids you can take in tow with you to court. Offer to take a drug test; the court probably won’t take you up on that. (But don’t do that if you will test positive . . . !)

An attorney doesn’t really have any legal expertise to bring here and a judge may resent it or feel you have something to hide. The only way you need an attorney is if the judge decides against you. Then get an attorney and file a motion to reargue or commence an Article 78 proceeding. Or, if you want to go for the full Monty, you can challenge by bring a 1983 case in Federal court.

Unfortunately notwithstanding the Heller and MacDonald cases, the current state of the law in New York is that a pistol license is a privilege and not a right. Don’t demand anything. Ask nicely.

And make sure to wear a suit, a tie, hide any tats, etc. Appearances count.
Click to expand...

This !!!

I did a little stupid in my earlier years and was denied for my permit , I turned around and filed an appeal THEN consulted with a 2A attorney .
The attorney I spoke to said it would be wise to speak for myself at my hearing for my appeal . He gave me some rather important instructions and I followed them to the T and 1 month later after my hearing I received an approval letter from the judge !
You must convince the judge you know you had done stupid and you have to much to lose today to do stupid again !!
I’m not in your county nor am I familiar with the gun climate there . Good luck
 
Last edited:
A

Austin

.38 Special
Messages
45
Reaction score
6
Location
Putnam county
BMF JK said:
This !!!

I did a little stupid in my earlier years and was denied for my permit , I turned around and filed an appeal THEN consulted with a 2A attorney .
The attorney I spoke to said it would be wise to speak for myself at my hearing for my appeal . He gave me some rather important instructions and I followed them to the T and 1 month later after my hearing I received an approval letter from the judge !
You must convince the judge you know you had done stupid and you have to much to lose today to do stupid again !!
I’m not in your county nor am I familiar with the gun climate there . Good luck
Click to expand...
Thanks so much.
Just curious how long ago was that and what county?
Thanks again
 
BMF JK

BMF JK

.44 mag
Messages
842
Reaction score
1,916
Location
Genesee county
Austin said:
Oh ok. Putnam I think is a little stricter but I guess it's worth a shot and possibly save a lot of money. How many charges did you have if you don't mind my asking?
Click to expand...

Number of charges are irrelevant , types of charges and any convictions is what matters. The more time you put between you and any past arrests the better . Remember be honest with the judge and prove that you haven’t caused trouble in a long time and you won’t any time in the future.
I’d recommend that if you have drug or alcohol related arrests in your past you might want to consider a drug and alcohol evaluation from a reputable counselor . That’s assuming your not currently doing any illegal drugs and you don’t have an alcohol abuse issue.
 
A

Austin

.38 Special
Messages
45
Reaction score
6
Location
Putnam county
BMF JK said:
Number of charges are irrelevant , types of charges and any convictions is what matters. The more time you put between you and any past arrests the better . Remember be honest with the judge and prove that you haven’t caused trouble in a long time and you won’t any time in the future.
I’d recommend that if you have drug or alcohol related arrests in your past you might want to consider a drug and alcohol evaluation from a reputable counselor . That’s assuming your not currently doing any illegal drugs and you don’t have an alcohol abuse issue.
Click to expand...
Ok thanks I will take ur advice also I'm getting a character evaluation
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top