A decade after the SAFE Act, gun policy polarization continues

Catskillkid

Catskillkid

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
10,085
Reaction score
18,434
Location
Livin' in a Gangsta's Paradise (AKA New York)
Grimscale said:
Has there ever been a pure unSAFE Act arrest that led to an actual unSAFE Act conviction, or did they, as usual, offer the perp a lower charge as a "deal" to prevent it from ever being challenged in court?
Click to expand...

To my knowledge there has never been a "pure" SAFE Act arrest. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Cavalry

Cavalry

.338 Win Mag
Messages
5,006
Reaction score
8,796
Location
Behind Enemy Lines
Catskillkid said:
To my knowledge there has never been a "pure" SAFE Act arrest. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
Click to expand...
There is a case in process currently.

Pure Safe Act Arrest?

https://leaderherald.com/gloversville-local-news-johnstown-local-news/local-news/2022/12/police-detail-weapons-seized-from-amsterdam-alderman/ Cliff notes- Homeslice, who happens to be a city council member, told a friend he wanted to off himself and the police intervened. Cops put him on 72...
nygunforum.com nygunforum.com
 
T

Truebeliever

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,490
Reaction score
1,622
Location
Nys
Cavalry said:
There is a case in process currently.

Pure Safe Act Arrest?

https://leaderherald.com/gloversville-local-news-johnstown-local-news/local-news/2022/12/police-detail-weapons-seized-from-amsterdam-alderman/ Cliff notes- Homeslice, who happens to be a city council member, told a friend he wanted to off himself and the police intervened. Cops put him on 72...
nygunforum.com nygunforum.com
Click to expand...
Not a pure safe act. The rifle had THREE ( pistol grip, a forward grip and a flash suspensor ) evil features as well as 30 round magazine. I believe it was illegal before the SAFE act.
 
Cavalry

Cavalry

.338 Win Mag
Messages
5,006
Reaction score
8,796
Location
Behind Enemy Lines
Truebeliever said:
Not a pure safe act. The rifle had THREE ( pistol grip, a forward grip and a flash suspensor ) evil features as well as 30 round magazine. I believe it was illegal before the SAFE act.
Click to expand...
The old law has no bearing on the new one. But yes we can assume that it was not a pre '94 since DD was started in 2000ish. The 30 round mag very well could have been a pre 94 dated GI mag, or it could have been a p-mag made 6 months ago. We do not have that information.

Without more information we dont know a lot of things. Was this brought in from out of state in that configuration? Was it mag locked and then converted? Was it mag locked and in compliance, but they dont care? Was it purchaced when he was LEO and it was ok for him to buy?
My biggest question is who plunks down $2K+ on an "illegal" rifle, but only has one 30 round magazine?
 
T

Truebeliever

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,490
Reaction score
1,622
Location
Nys
Cavalry said:
The old law has no bearing on the new one. But yes we can assume that it was not a pre '94 since DD was started in 2000ish. The 30 round mag very well could have been a pre 94 dated GI mag, or it could have been a p-mag made 6 months ago. We do not have that information.

Without more information we dont know a lot of things. Was this brought in from out of state in that configuration? Was it mag locked and then converted? Was it mag locked and in compliance, but they dont care? Was it purchaced when he was LEO and it was ok for him to buy?
My biggest question is who plunks down $2K+ on an "illegal" rifle, but only has one 30 round magazine?
Click to expand...
I didn’t mention the magazine for the very reason you mention. But the rifle was illegal before the safe act therefore it’s not a pure safe act violation.
Once this CCIA bs is defeated in court , the “ assault rifle” evil feature bans should be on the list to be challenged.
 
Cooolone

Cooolone

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,267
Reaction score
9,700
Location
NY, USA
A decade later and the State has never admitted how many complied...

Lmao!

Because they would never admit the law was an utter failure!

That is all...


Here's a copy from a Gun Forum Post in a Free State (to which I'm moving) lol...

For sale: Direct form 4 to NC residents:
Sterling MK6/L2A3 w/3 sterling roller mags: ...$19,900
MAC M10-45 w/suppressor (2 stamp transfer) 7 mags and spare .45 Upper &9mm Conversion w/2 mags ...$12,000
M1 THOMPSON .45 built by RW Urich. w/ GI sling & canvas case 2 20 rd & 4 30 rd mags ...$30,000
S&H HK Sear installed in HK33/93A2 (16" bbl. sear is unmarried to the weapon) w/it factory folding bipod, 1 20 rd, 1 25 rd & 2 40 rd mags ...$45,000
RARE: Transferable Beretta BM59 Nigerian model by Springfield Armory w/3 20 rd mags: $18,000
MAC M10A1A 9mm & .45 NEW in Box: ....$12,000
Dead Air MASK22 MASK-HD .22 silencer, 1/2x28 direct thread new in box: ...$400.00
Thunder Beast Arms Corp. (TBAC) Ultra -7 .30 cal CB Gen 2. FDE color. New in box, no CB Brake or flash hider, ...$1000
Hi-TEC TPM Outfitters TPM SD 12" HP5SD silencer, direct thread HK MP5SD silencer. New in box ...$600
Click to expand...

Just a few days away... And yeah, you bet your ass I'll be checking some Class-3 shit out for sure! ASAP!

:D

FUNY
 
ArmedCorgi

ArmedCorgi

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
14,422
Reaction score
22,645
Location
Utahardia
It will be great if the court rules in our favor. The problem is the second ciruit. If we win in the lower court the second circuit will likely slow walk it and I doubt they would rule in our favor. The only hope would be that they would rule quickly so we can get it in front of the supreme court. AWB cases are popping up in a lot of places, so one is bound to make it there. Just have to hope it's soon.
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
35,351
Reaction score
39,761
Location
Western NY
Catskillkid said:
To my knowledge there has never been a "pure" SAFE Act arrest. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
Click to expand...
Yes there has been. I’m aware of a few but they were not prosecuted. I know a lot of cops and a guy was selling guns without background checks but the judge tossed it because he wanted a jury trial. I also know of a Canadian being arrested for a full featured AR-15 in NYS.
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
35,882
Reaction score
38,440
Location
Livingston
Saltwater60 said:
Yes there has been. I’m aware of a few but they were not prosecuted. I know a lot of cops and a guy was selling guns without background checks but the judge tossed it because he wanted a jury trial. I also know of a Canadian being arrested for a full featured AR-15 in NYS.
Click to expand...

arrests and lose of jobs and $$$$$$ later Charges droped .. NYS does not want a conviction .. would give the person major Standing ..

and the best part is they give you the same gun back that they arrested you for it . . with all its evil plastic attachments still on it ..

and the shoulder flip up full auto device ..
 
R

REF

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
1,518
Reaction score
3,283
Location
Nassau
Grimscale said:
Do they actually return the person's property?
I thought they simply kept or destroy it and tell the person "we're dropping the charges but the gun is illegal so you can't have it back."
Click to expand...
Yeah, I find it very difficult to believe that NY, with their draconian laws ,would arrest you for having an evil, scary looking , baby slaying, fully featured “assault “rifle , then lower the charges to something minuscule, and then give you your death machine back to bring home. If that’s the case , the arrest was bogus from the start. Arrest you for something, charge you for something else, and then give you back what you unlawfully possessed and were arrested for in the first place????? Just don’t see that happening,
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
35,882
Reaction score
38,440
Location
Livingston
Grimscale said:
Do they actually return the person's property?
I thought they simply kept or destroy it and tell the person "we're dropping the charges but the gun is illegal so you can't have it back."
Click to expand...

yes .. my brother was arrested for a 10/22 with all the evil plastic .. then got it back a year or so later along with all the other guns they took .

i would argue since they dropped the safe act charges .. they either have to give it back or pay you for it ..

dropping the charge is .. is like .. ohhh my bad .. don't tell daddy / mommy ..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top