Don't forget the Mets tickets and Obummer phone!
Buffalo PD emergency response team resigns over old man shove
- Thread starter Saltwater60
- Start date
So is Martin the old man or the cop?
Dr. Evil
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Certain situations are clear cut. Certain ones are not. It is very easy to sit here in my living room and critique the situation on the video. I'm sure the emotional tone makes a big difference though. Tension, your sympathetic nervous system (fight or flight) kicks in and you have your head on a swivel. Situations can get out of control in an instant and lives can be lost in the blink of an eye. Honestly, the shove really didn't seem overly aggressive. Was it necessary? I don't know as I wasn't there and had zero perspective. Did the old guy talk shit to them at the same time? I also noticed how the news story emphasized he was 75. To me that's not here nor there. Just like many would say a man never should hit a woman. Overall I tend to agree but I would have no problem doing that very thing though if one of these ANTIFA babes was getting in my face and laying a hand on me making it physical if that was necessary. IMHO, don't put yourself in the position to make a situation like this a possibility. Don't stick out your chest and ruffle your feathers to a line of police officers in gear that are walking in a line during an obvious hostile situation and climate.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
I don’t know either of their names.
I've seen the video from multiple angles. The more I watch it the more I think he wanted to get pushed.
I saw his head fall with a lot of velocity and hit the concrete with a lot of force. I think the dude was definitely injured. He at least has a concussion possibly more injuries.
However, that is an interesting observation. If he was deliberately trying to provoke the police I suppose it's entirely possible he would go the extra mile to really sell the brutality. Who knows. If he was knocked out like it appears I doubt he would be cognizant enough to deploy fake blood.
Carlos Hathcock
.338 Win Mag
People cry out that protesters are turning riotous......burning, looting, and assaulting. The police are called to enforce a curfew to help quell the rioters. Police enforce the curfew, people refuse or resist, police end up hurting someone and the public is pissed
Die? I think not. This picture was taken four, yes four, minutes after the push/fall. He is fine.
He wasn’t “hobbling along”. He was there after curfew, and was attempting to obstruct the cops from sweeping the plaza as they were in the middle of doing. He came directly at them while they were in the midst of it.
So, I posted the following pictures elsewhere on the forum.
I will re-post here, I did not realize there was a separate thread about this fine gentleman.
First thing is first. A word of warning..... If you are going to set up the Police, cancel your Twitter feed and your Facebook. Very important first step.
I will re-post here, I did not realize there was a separate thread about this fine gentleman.
First thing is first. A word of warning..... If you are going to set up the Police, cancel your Twitter feed and your Facebook. Very important first step.
Carlos Hathcock
.338 Win Mag
Perhaps this incident bears a little more "investigation".
It looks like a doubled up mask to me.
I still think he was in the wrong though.
I still think he was in the wrong though.
Mr. terzmo
.308 Win
This guy was barely touched. He was clearly too fragile to be out there acting tough. That’s his problem.
So being fragile restricts any part of the Constitution YOU deem. You're on the clock...just as the rest of US and I if YOU get shit on later in life because of physical condition remember your words. Live it up...you're body/mind has a shelf life
So being fragile restricts any part of the Constitution YOU deem. You're on the clock...just as the rest of US and I if YOU get shit on later in life because of physical condition remember your words. Live it up...you're body/mind has a shelf life
Release the CT scan!! Release the CT scan!!
Vapor
6.5 Creedmoor
Mentally there is a bit of a double standard here.
If some jack ass gets in my face at wal mart for some perceived slight, I'm supposed to wait until he's literally trying to kill me to even touch him. Otherwise, at least in this state, I'm a violent offender. I better hope the force I apply is deemed "proportionate" or else I'm in the shit. See, my beef is the "better than" set up we have.
I don't fully know this situation here. Maybe those boys were already hopped up on adrenaline. Its happened to me. It's probably happened to a lot of us. I'm not passing judgment on this situation.
Still, I get tired of the bootlicker mentality of "you get what you deserve."
If some jack ass gets in my face at wal mart for some perceived slight, I'm supposed to wait until he's literally trying to kill me to even touch him. Otherwise, at least in this state, I'm a violent offender. I better hope the force I apply is deemed "proportionate" or else I'm in the shit. See, my beef is the "better than" set up we have.
I don't fully know this situation here. Maybe those boys were already hopped up on adrenaline. Its happened to me. It's probably happened to a lot of us. I'm not passing judgment on this situation.
Still, I get tired of the bootlicker mentality of "you get what you deserve."
Chevusa
.338 Win Mag
gun_slinger_boy
.308 Win
Steal2B
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Went through this thread and want to add I am a bit ticked the video at the beginning of this thread convieniently edits out the few seconds showing the "old victim" (in my perspective 75 is the new 50 and this is not a frail unhealthy specimen) getting up in the officers' face. I had previously seen video of the victim a few minutes and a few seconds before the encounter and the asshole was out of line to run up and stop short of an approaching line. The video showing a few minutes was "no longer available" but this shows a few seconds.
I am also ticked with the media's playing of the frail elder card for everyone over 50, 55, 60, 65, 70, 75 because it sweetens their narritive / headline / clickbait. In that 25 year spread many who have moderately maintained themselves or were genetically blessed could be a formidable unarmed foe. On the other hand I have no doubt if there was a video of FUAC or Fredo starting a brush up with me, there would no mention or sympathy of my senior citizen age and it would be cast as an unfair encounter when in retaliation I rip off their heads and shit down their throats. Just saying ...
I am also ticked with the media's playing of the frail elder card for everyone over 50, 55, 60, 65, 70, 75 because it sweetens their narritive / headline / clickbait. In that 25 year spread many who have moderately maintained themselves or were genetically blessed could be a formidable unarmed foe. On the other hand I have no doubt if there was a video of FUAC or Fredo starting a brush up with me, there would no mention or sympathy of my senior citizen age and it would be cast as an unfair encounter when in retaliation I rip off their heads and shit down their throats. Just saying ...
Last edited:
Blimey
.338 Win Mag
Forget that these are police for a moment.So gestapo tactics are OK as long as you disagree with the politics of the victim.
Got it.
You're walking down the sidewalk and a 75 year old gets in your face and is blocking your movement aggressively, with no intention of moving. This is a crime, by the way.
You push him back out of the way, just to gain space so you can continue on. He hits his head and is in the hospital. What did you do wrong?
Blimey
.338 Win Mag
How does that work?
"Sir, you're blocking our way, can Office Robinson please have a word with you off to the side? Thank you sir, we really appreciate it, now please be on your way."
Nope. Here is how that works:
Cop one tries to restrain him. He resists. Then cop 2, then you have 3-4 cops "wrestling 75 year old". And that poor, poor senior just being manhandled by cops. Oh my God the humanity.
Nope. This guy went in looking for a confrontation and he got exactly what he wanted.
Mr. terzmo
.308 Win
To all of the people supporting the results of a 75 year old being shoved....what if the cops pushed your wife..daughter...son...girlfriend...boyfriend...mother ...father ..and the same results happened ? Saying they wouldn't be there or doing that does not apply as this could happen anywhere at any time.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Funny. What would look better? An old man resisting when being pulled to the side or pushed back and injured? I swear some of you just cannot get past bias. No different than the people you oppose.
Steal2B
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Bullshit hypothetical and Asinine question, this did not happen happen just anywhere at anytime. Where it happened, when it happened and how it happened are always factors. Period.
The "victim" was not without fault in this encounter. It is a fact. Get over it.
And it is also true my wife ..daughter ...son ... girlfriend ... boyfriend... mother ... father would not rush up in to the face of a police line responding to a riot scene.
Similarly if a 75 year old asshole rushed up in to the face of my wife ..daughter ...son ... girlfriend ... boyfriend... mother ... father, I would expect them to protect their space.
Edit: Modified response to stress I have a wife and girlfriends and boyfriends are platonic relationships
Last edited:
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
But if they did whether knowingly or not, you’d expect them to be treated correctly. Even if they were dead wrong.
And similarly if a 75 year old entered your space, you’d treat him differently than a 20 year old.
None of my family would have touched a police officer while doing his job. Maybe yours would, but not mine!
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
BS argument. None of my family would push a 75 year old either. One has nothing to do with the other.
Disclaimer.... The officer didn’t mean to do it. It was an accident. The response afterwards seems to be the issue.
Disclaimer.... The officer didn’t mean to do it. It was an accident. The response afterwards seems to be the issue.
I would hope they would be smart enough not to interfere with a line of cops in riot gear preparing to clear out a mob of angry rioters.
If not, they get what's coming to them.