House passes concealed carry gun bill in win for GOP and NRA

Discussion in 'General Firearm Talk' started by zorro, Dec 6, 2017.

  1. zorro

    zorro .177 BB

    2
    1
    3
    http://politi.co/2k2yqC7

    So, what’s next ..........does it need to go to the senate for final approval..?

    Quote

    "It uses the power of the federal government to import the law in the one state into another state so that New York would have to allow concealed-carry permits approved in Texas, even if Texas has no standards whatsoever."
     
  2. HighlandLofts

    HighlandLofts .357 mag

    741
    520
    118
    I urge every one of you to call your representitive on HR38 for them to fully support it.
    Phone calls and e mails really help.
     
  3. FrankenCub

    FrankenCub .223 Rem

    1,221
    1,044
    158
    :ROFL::ROFL::ROFL:My reps don't think we should own slingshots. If every voter in the state told them to support it they will still vote NO.
     
    timboy, MoMan, Criticalt and 6 others like this.
  4. kev74

    kev74 .308 Win Monthly Shot Winner

    3,398
    5,333
    178
    Chuckles and Gili-no eyebrows-brand won't be swayed by calls and letters? Say it ain't so!
     
  5. Exonautic

    Exonautic .223 Rem

    1,158
    844
    128
    unfortunately as New Yorkers we are capable of doing nothing in the case of the senate pushing this bill through unless we start calling out of state senators.
     
    Edwardteach72 likes this.
  6. Cooolone

    Cooolone .223 Rem

    1,253
    1,423
    148
    NY is a special brand of politics... Even if passed, they will fight it all the way to the SCOTUS with little doubt! In the mean time, someone in NY (visiting) would become the lab rat and once arrested will also have to fight and not take a deal... And probably when my grandkids (don't have any currently) grow old, some BS decision will be made about their Rights, whereas the privilege of driving from State to State goes on with little notice or fanfare!
     
  7. Podmonkey

    Podmonkey .338 Win Mag Monthly Shot Winner U.S. Military

    8,025
    8,106
    178
    This was passed with the "fix NICS" portion attached?
     
  8. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78
    I believe so. I'm also wonder what other amendments it had riding along. IE bump stocks are super deadly after being used only one time ever in a crime so let's ban them amendment
     
  9. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78

    Even if someone became the "lab rat" the way the bill is written NY would be paying them all that money back
     
  10. Saltwater60

    Saltwater60 .308 Win

    3,167
    2,109
    178
    While I'm happy to have it it also sets presidence for the Feds to play in gun laws. Right now we're good, but what about when the control flips and the dems are in control of everything. What could they do because this was implemented. I don't know I'm a bit scared for the future. If this goes through I'm going to NYC with my gun just to say I did it.
     
  11. Willjr75

    Willjr75 .338 Win Mag U.S. Military

    8,490
    6,726
    178
  12. eagleridge357

    eagleridge357 .223 Rem

    1,040
    787
    148
    What, no anti-NRA wisecracks yet?
     
  13. Onegunnotenough

    Onegunnotenough .40 S&W

    104
    65
    38
    I don't see what all the fuss is all about. We didn't win anything, yes, its nice it passed the house,but it needs to be passed into law, so now on to the senate. It has a slim to none chance unless backroom deals can be made, as of now it will fall short, so keep ur fingers crossed. This will be incredible if it passes. But its a near impossible climb, so lets be real about it.
     
  14. Onegunnotenough

    Onegunnotenough .40 S&W

    104
    65
    38
    does anyone know when the senate will take this up? Is it now, or in a month, year?
     
  15. BuffNiag

    BuffNiag .38 Special

    36
    20
    8
    I think we need a few more threads for this topic.
     
  16. Phazer

    Phazer .308 Win

    3,173
    4,777
    178
    .....ever?
     
    Edwardteach72 likes this.
  17. Exonautic

    Exonautic .223 Rem

    1,158
    844
    128
    They're already trying to accomplish that, so ccr or not, if they hey control expect an assault weapons ban to be shoved down our throats.
     
  18. ManrisFrack

    ManrisFrack .45 acp

    381
    412
    83
    Right after the lab rat brings a second lawsuit (that will also have to climb the court system to find a just ruling) to force compliance.
     
  19. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78
    What lawsuit, the bill specifically states the state would have to pay
     
    Willjr75 likes this.
  20. ManrisFrack

    ManrisFrack .45 acp

    381
    412
    83
    And if you think NY will pay up without a fight, you're not paying one lick of attention.
     
    eagleridge357 likes this.
  21. Willjr75

    Willjr75 .338 Win Mag U.S. Military

    8,490
    6,726
    178
    I don't know why people don't just read the bill before making assumptions.
     
    Edwardteach72 likes this.
  22. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78
    Are you guys not reading the text in the Bill?
    Screenshot_20171207-102605.png
     
    Defilade and Willjr75 like this.
  23. ManrisFrack

    ManrisFrack .45 acp

    381
    412
    83
    I don't know why you think that NYS will willingly abide by this law? The fact that they still convict people of mere possession of a handgun without a license shows that they have zero respect for federal rulings or laws.
     
  24. Willjr75

    Willjr75 .338 Win Mag U.S. Military

    8,490
    6,726
    178
    Besides the 2A which is ignored there is no federal law about reciprocity for possession of a handgun.
     
    Phazer likes this.
  25. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78
    This statement about possession if a handgun and federal law makes no sense
     
    REF likes this.
  26. ManrisFrack

    ManrisFrack .45 acp

    381
    412
    83
    Guys, this has been beat to death before. Heller specifically mentions, and subsequently protects, possession of handguns in the home. Our state law still says that possession is illegal ANYWHERE. Permits merely provide an affirmative defense against this. They cherry pick indictments and pleas so that the blatant unconstitutionality of this is never challenged.

    Back to my point - if you think NYS will go along with this without fighting tooth and nail, you're naive.

    ETA: Suppose they bring some poor schmuck up on charges and he eventually wins at SCOTUS. The state will probably be ordered to pay as part of the decision. But what happens if the state decides not to pay? If the schmuck doesn't keep up the legal pressure there's a real chance that money never shows up.
     
    Last edited: Dec 7, 2017
  27. ArmedCorgi

    ArmedCorgi .308 Win

    3,399
    3,801
    178
    I mean, one could take that text to include that even your home state may not deprive you. If that is the case, I see a way for people to sue their judges over restrictions Etc. and win. So with so many states with different laws, the question becomes a matter of what is the standard? Unless I missed where it said you are bound by the regulations of your home state regardless if they are more or less restrictive than the state you are visiting, and other states simply have to oblige you and honor your permit and the laws of your along state with it.
     
  28. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78
    Cuomo already said he was going to sue if they pass it . So the fuck what, just because he sues doesn' stop the law from being the law until it is eventually picked up by a court and they put a hold on it which that isn' going to happen for just one state, and then finally a court rules that the law is not a law or is a law.

    In the mean time if signed by the potus and once it takes affect guess what that's the law again until a court decides if they want to hear the case or not and then has a ruling, then come the appeals
     
  29. @thewheels

    @thewheels .45 acp

    476
    479
    63
    Let him sue. Water under the bridge by that time. If this passes the senate.
     
  30. Edwardteach72

    Edwardteach72 .357 mag

    651
    386
    78
    That's what I am trying to say
     
Loading...

Share This Page