NYSRPA v. Bruen, NY 2A Case Supreme Court case and decision

Cavalry

Cavalry

.338 Win Mag
Messages
5,097
Reaction score
8,930
Location
Behind Enemy Lines
spat said:
Arizona has an interesting approach to that.

Businesses are allowed to forbid guns on their premises, but if they want their signs to have force of law they need to provide secure storage for the guns.

Just slapping a sign on the door isn't sufficient, they need to actively participate in disarming their patrons.
Click to expand...
What NY wants to do is opposite of what TX did with 30.05/30.06/30.07 signs with the default being no guns allowed. TX had a particular standard for the sign, size, wording, location etc. From what I have read the permitted sign in NY just has to indicate (from horechuls quote) 'something to the extent of concealed carry allowed'. As of now there does not appear to be a standard of language size etc.

If this is the case, what stops freedom loving vandals from slapping a preprinted 4x6 Avery label on the door to shithole walmart as they enter?
Muddy the waters as much as possible on where its permitted or not. The minions will get sick of scraping the stickers off the doors eventually and just leave them.
 
maverick52

maverick52

.223 Rem
Messages
1,114
Reaction score
2,197
Location
Knowhere
spat said:
They will do it like they did covid.

They will extort the business owners into prohibiting it against their will.

Then some idiots will defend that as being the private property rights of the businesses that were forced to do that against their will.

They'll add it as a condition of the business license or something.

"Your normal license requires you to prohibit firearms, bit for an extra $1000/year you can have the enhanced license that allows it, and also adds a bunch of additional onerous requirements".

Then when the business that doesn't really want to prohibit anything sees someone printing, they'll have to call the cops or risk their license.

Then the cops show up and trespass the guy and say to themselves "the owner has a right to post his property" as if it was his choice to do so.
Click to expand...
I almost forgot the whole Covid shot laws.
 
spat

spat

.700 Nitro Express
Messages
29,953
Reaction score
63,175
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
maverick52 said:
I almost forgot the whole Covid shot laws.
Click to expand...
I was thinking more of the mask requirement bullshit.

We even had people here who defended the "right" of businesses to require that, completely ignoring the fact that many of them were forced to require them against their will.

That's like saying the sex was consensual because she asked for it, even though the guy with the knife demanded she do so.
 
N

nobody

22lr
Messages
16
Reaction score
30
Location
NY
So nobody stuck around for the summary dispositions? (edit: except nobody)

BIANCHI, DOMINIC, ET AL. V. FROSH, ATT'Y GEN. OF MD, ET AL.

ASSN. OF NJ RIFLE, ET AL. V. BRUCK, ATT'Y GEN. OF NJ, ET AL.

YOUNG, GEORGE K. V. HAWAII, ET AL.

DUNCAN, VIRGINIA, ET AL. V. BONTA, ATT'Y GEN. OF CA

...all vacated and remanded back to lower courts for further consideration in light of New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn., Inc. v. Bruen
 
Last edited:
Edwardteach72

Edwardteach72

.475 A&M Magnum
U.S. Military
Messages
14,883
Reaction score
15,052
Location
New York
nobody said:
hint:

These would be challenges to; assault weapons bans, magazine capacity limits, California's 2A craziness, and another permit denial.

Big day.
Click to expand...

Yuuup, huge day.. Young is meh but the others are big.

Downside when they are sent back to the Circuit courts (9th, 4th and 3rd) their new ruling would only affect the states in their jurisdiction. But the good news is those rulings can/will be used in future cases hopefully here in NY and the 2nd circuit
 
nortatoga

nortatoga

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,422
Reaction score
19,166
Location
Saratoga County
Edwardteach72 said:
Yuuup, huge day.. Young is meh but the others are big.

Downside when they are sent back to the Circuit courts (9th, 4th and 3rd) their new ruling would only affect the states in their jurisdiction. But the good news is those rulings can/will be used in future cases hopefully here in NY and the 2nd circuit
Click to expand...

Young could be a bigger case then you think!
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
35,854
Reaction score
40,313
Location
Western NY
spat said:
Arizona has an interesting approach to that.

Businesses are allowed to forbid guns on their premises, but if they want their signs to have force of law they need to provide secure storage for the guns.

Just slapping a sign on the door isn't sufficient, they need to actively participate in disarming their patrons.
Click to expand...
That is interesting and IMO worse than doing nothing. There are some yahoos that don’t know how to holster their weapons properly. Also it’s voluntary to participate right? By voluntary I mean I can walk in with a gun concealed and not say anything and the vast majority of times no o e would ever even know.
 
Z

Zerex

.308 Win
Messages
3,080
Reaction score
2,433
Location
Rome, NY
Stop and Frisk is as dead as a dodo...............no store owner can lay a hand on you and frisk you...cops either.

Unless you are determined to flash a belt carry holster, almost openly, and shout to the world........".FUCK YOU-- IN YOUR FACE", like Rambo, no one will ever know ,OR SHOULD KNOW, that you are carrying a gun concealed, legally..........women carry on purses all the time.

Be like James Bond..the law is now on your side.

On the first 48 the other night, in 2019, Tusla cops lead a skinny short, 120 lb women out in cuffs, then frisked her, and she was concealing a glock in her tight yoga pants , in her rear end area...could not be detected except by frisking.

CONCEALED CARRY IS NOT OPEN CARRY.
 
G

Glock_USA

.45 acp
Messages
379
Reaction score
637
Location
NY
Saltwater60 said:
That is interesting and IMO worse than doing nothing. There are some yahoos that don’t know how to holster their weapons properly. Also it’s voluntary to participate right? By voluntary I mean I can walk in with a gun concealed and not say anything and the vast majority of times no o e would ever even know.
Click to expand...
The proper procedure is to remove the gun while it remains in the holster. They are one. The weapon should never come out. You lock them up together.
 
G

Glock_USA

.45 acp
Messages
379
Reaction score
637
Location
NY
Zerex said:
Stop and Frisk is as dead as a dodo...............no store owner can lay a hand on you and frisk you...cops either.

Unless you are determined to flash a belt carry holster, almost openly, and shout to the world........".FUCK YOU-- IN YOUR FACE", like Rambo, no one will ever know ,OR SHOULD KNOW, that you are carrying a gun concealed, legally..........women carry on purses all the time.

Be like James Bond..the law is now on your side.

On the first 48 the other night, in 2019, Tusla cops lead a skinny short, 120 lb women out in cuffs, then frisked her, and she was concealing a glock in her tight yoga pants , in her rear end area...could not be detected except by frisking.

CONCEALED CARRY IS NOT OPEN CARRY.
Click to expand...
It's not stop and frisk. In any police encounter they have the right to pat down for weapons. This is long upheld. All it takes is a suspicion for there to be an encounter.
 
Z

Zerex

.308 Win
Messages
3,080
Reaction score
2,433
Location
Rome, NY
If you have an unrestricted NYS PP, it was always concealed carry.............you could carry in your car, on your person, it is the intent of the law, BE ARMED................no such restriction ever existed for unrestricted licenses......... and that is what we have now.........unrestricted licenses............no locked box in trunk, no separate ammo anymore.
clips............


If you are under arrest for DWI, you will be frisked before being cuffed.................I am not aware of a normal, non gang citizen being stopped and frisked "for safety", by MALL Cops, or in the supermarket, or parts store, or driving around normally.

Be discreet, as always. No one should know you are carrying.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top