US and Iran conflict thread. ( merged threads)

[GOPerfect]

The U.S. Constitution divides war powers between Congress and the President. Article I, Section 8 grants Congress the power to declare war, raise and support armies, and provide for a navy. Article II, Section 2 designates the President as Commander in Chief of the armed forces. This division of power necessitates cooperation between the two branches regarding military affairs.



Here's a more detailed breakdown:
Congress's Powers:

• Declare War: Congress has the sole power to formally declare war.
  

• Raise and Support Armies: Congress can raise and fund the army and navy.
  
  

• Make Rules for the Military: Congress can establish rules and regulations for the armed forces.
  

• Appropriate Funds: Congress controls the purse strings, meaning they decide how much money is spent on the military.
  

President's Powers:

• • Commander in Chief: The President is the supreme commander of the military.
    

• Initiate Military Action: While Congress declares war, the President can initiate military action in response to an attack or under specific authorization from Congress.
  

 

[GOPerfect]

Legal Definition:

• 18 US Code § 2331(4)
  .

defines an "act of war" as any action occurring during declared war, armed conflict between nations, or armed conflict between military forces

Us bombing another country does not mean an armed conflict. If they never fight back, no conflict....

 

[holdover]

If we hit enriched uranium sites: Is there any measurable radiation leakage at these locations?

It would be a perfect way to use tactical nukes. Hey the site is leaking radiation.

 

[4WHLDRFTN]

 

[TEOTWAWKI inc.]

$10 says Trump made him do that.

 

[4WHLDRFTN]

$10 says Trump made him do that.

Nobody will fk with the US anymore.

 

[dwa12479]

When "someone" destroyed the twin towers the US considered it an act of war. What would we have done if they took out our nuclear facilities.

The libs like to declare ARs as "weapons of war"... doesnt make them so

 

[tirwin1]

Not sure if this is really Iran. But if it is it just kinda sorta looks nuclear.

 

[SomeSoldier]

The libs like to declare ARs as "weapons of war"... doesnt make them so

Whatever play semantics.

 

[tirwin1]

• Initiate Military Action: While Congress declares war, the President can initiate military action in response to an attack or under specific authorization from Congress.

Trump didn't have specific authorization from Congress and it wasn't in response to an attack. So how is this legal?

 

[GOPerfect]

Trump didn't have specific authorization from Congress and it wasn't in response to an attack. So how is this legal?

According to his words tonight, he used past attacks to partly justify this action.

 

[CaseHardened]

US has bombed three nuclear sites in Iran, Trump announces: ‘Now is the time for peace’

The attack came days after President Trump unleashed an open threat to Tehran to give up its nuclear program and called for Iran’s “unconditional surrender.”

nypost.com

 

[CaseHardened]

Today will go down in history as one of America's finest moments.

 

[GOPerfect]

Another Iran thread........

 

[CaseHardened]

GOP leaders, Sen. John Fetterman commend Trump’s strikes on Iran: ‘The correct move’

“As I’ve long maintained, this was the correct move by @POTUS,” the Pennsylvania Democrat posted on X.

nypost.com

 

[CaseHardened]

I think a person really has to be born prior to 1967 to have been old enough to understand the intense, visceral hatred we have for these Ayatollahs. Who sprang into power in 1979, thanks to Jimmy Carter; a worthless, feckless man who never should have been president.

And when we hear the word Iran, these faces spring to mind.



These are Ayatollahs.

They are wretched pieces of sh1t that destroy every life around them - especially the muslims who have long suffered under their thumbs.

So yes, kill them all. And when one is deposited from the anus of Satan to replace the former, flush that one as well.

 

[CaseHardened]

I never thought it would ever happen.

 

[4WHLDRFTN]

LIVE | TOTAL CHAOS In Iran, US B2 Bombers Strike Nuclear Sites | Trump Bombs Fordow | Bunker Busters

The US military conducted air strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities in Fordow, Natanz and Isfahan on Sunday morning, President Trump announced. "We have comp...

www.youtube.com

 

[CaseHardened]

Unlike Iran, both America and Israel have not targeted civilians.

Military installations only.

 

[Bigfoot]

There are two other Iran threads already in progress discussing the most recent events.

Edit - Never mind, the threads have now been merged.

 

[Defilade]

So here comes....peace?

 

[spat]

If we hit enriched uranium sites: Is there any measurable radiation leakage at these locations?

Unlikely, since they are deeply buried sites.

Even if there was, it would be local contamination only.

 

[spat]

Trump didn't have specific authorization from Congress and it wasn't in response to an attack. So how is this legal?

The war powers act only requires the president to inform congress within 48 hours of mobilizing troops.

Then he has 60 days to prosecute whatever campaign he deems necessary. If congress hasn't approved the actions by then, he has another 15 ? days (IIRC) to withdraw the troops.

 

[spat]

Not sure if this is really Iran. But if it is it just kinda sorta looks nuclear.

The GBU-57 bunker busters penetrate 200 feet into the earth before detonating. There's probably not much to see.

There's some pics of a shallow underground nuclear explosion to compare here:

Sedan (nuclear test) - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

That test was deeper than fordow (600 feet vs 200) but the explosion was *much* bigger (104,000 tons of TNT equivalent vs only about 2.5 tons for the GBU-57).

So that's all it looks like when you're 3 times deeper, and 41,000 times as powerful.

 

[spat]

POTUS has the nuclear Football: He doesn't need permission from Congress or to even notify then, if and when he takes action...That said, only Congress has the power to declare War (even though the President either started or pulled us into one with his actions)

Legally he would have to inform them within 48 hours if he launched the nukes.

Pretty sure that'd be just a formality at that point.

 

[spat]

I was wondering that myself.

Is it enough to bomb the facilities if we can't actually recover the uranium or verify its destruction? It was enriched to at least 60% and enough of it for nine bombs if brought to weapons grade. I'd think that would still make for some decent dirty bombs. I wouldn't doubt if it was relocated given all the sabre-rattling.

ETA -

If you have enriched uranium and natural uranium (as you would at an enrichment facility), and you blow it up, you basically just un-enriched all of the expensive stuff.

Think of enrichment like this. You have a bin full of black sand with a tiny bit of red mixed in. About 60 pounds of sand, and 7 ounces of it are red grains.

To make your bomb, you need 5 ounces of red sand with no more than half an ounce of black mixed in.

You just spend a week painstakingly sorting it out so that you're now close. You have a jar with about 7 ounces of sand that's mostly red. You just need to pick out a few more black grains and you're good to go.

That jar is right next to the bin, and someone tosses in a hand grenade in the room and now it's all scattered around the place.

That's what blowing up an enrichment facility would look like.

 

[spat]

Did he start every day by telling everyone that he was planning to use his guns to kill all of his neighbors? If so, then yes.

Threats of credible violence are not protected speech.

If a guy holding a knife says he's going to stab you, you don't have to wait for him to swing it at you to eliminate the threat

 

[Podmonkey]

This was a terrible idea. Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria......... we have learned nothing.

 

[holdover]

I dont know if it will work but you can be dam sure the dems are going to push it

Well that was quick, less than 24 hours.

NEWS — Chuck Schumer says Congress must enforce the War Powers Act. “I’m urging Leader Thune to put it on the Senate floor immediately. I am voting for it and implore all Senators on both sides of the aisle to vote for it.” ( nothing will come of it, but they wont miss an opportunity to try)

 

[holdover]

If a guy holding a knife says he's going to stab you, you don't have to wait for him to swing it at you to eliminate the threat

except the guy with knife is in california and your in NY, then you fly to california eliminate the threat and claim self defense,LOL