Which new york county easiest to get permit?

M

mystery

.177 BB
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
USA
CT and NYC resident. Have CT, MA, UT, FL permits, no restrictions. RI in progress. Would like to carry in NY state / NYC, know its a long shot for NYC. Trying to figure out if I should try to obtain premises permits in NY and NYC first and then try to convert into carry (does that require re-applying?) or try to do NY state carry first and then try to get a special carry for NYC (out of city validation) as I dont think they will validate any of my other permits? MA is typically not easy to get non-resident non-restricted but I referenced my career history (included investigating cyber criminals / financial crimes) and being threatened before and they approved without question.

For NY state, I have a boat that I use as a residence 7-8 months of the year and do spend time in NY, living on the boat, usually on rented moorings or transient docks. I read the recent ruling, and at quick glance I did see it mention "owning" a residence... would someone renting be restricted? I can see a case being made if I get a mooring permit in my name, buy mooring tackle, and have dropped in either Westchester, Nassau, or Suffolk county, allowing me to hook-up my boat and spend indefinite amounts of time living on my boat in one of those counties.

I am trying to figure out which of those three counties is easiest for a part-time resident to obtain a carry permit? I can probably more easily get character references in Nassau county but could potentially find in Westchester & Suffolk as well.

Thank you for your thoughts!
 
turbobike

turbobike

.44 mag
Messages
870
Reaction score
1,719
Location
Leroy
Genesee county has really relaxed the permit process, since the Anti-2nd-Judge retired. 6-8 weeks from start to finish. No restrictions....
 
togmaster

togmaster

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
13,260
Reaction score
19,963
Location
Buoy 42
Westchester and Nassau will be restricted. Suffolk I don't know. I would suggest looking for a mooring on the Hudson in Putnam County. The Cold Spring area is beautiful.
 
ArmedCorgi

ArmedCorgi

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
14,425
Reaction score
22,650
Location
Utahardia
Rensselaer will put restrictions on your permit unless you are lucky enough to get the one judge who issues unrestricted right off the bat. The process is bottle necked by the finger printing part with the Sheriff's department.
 
Toecutter

Toecutter

.308 Win
Messages
3,967
Reaction score
8,629
Location
Putnam , NY
Putnam in the past has been easy. Just took time but they would give you a carry . I went through the process a few years ago things may have changed . new judges clerks and sheriff.
 
Bigfoot

Bigfoot

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
16,109
Reaction score
42,400
Location
On the Trump Train
turbobike said:
Genesee county has really relaxed the permit process, since the Anti-2nd-Judge retired. 6-8 weeks from start to finish. No restrictions....
Click to expand...

That's good to read, I know that retired Judge Noonan sucked when it came to PP's and the 2A in general.
That is one of the reasons that I never bothered applying for mine. I figured that I would just wait him out knowing that his time was getting short. And then wait to see if the Judge that replaces Noonan was more 2A friendly. But now, I'm not so sure that I want to do that as it could possibly put all of my long guns at risk. but that's a different discussion for a different thread.

A little off topic again, Years back my wife worked at the "Batavia Men's Club" making the guys their lunch etc.
The club consisted of the successful well to do businessmen in the area.
She really liked that job, she said that all of the guy's were great.
Well, except for Judge Noonan... She did not like him at all... Just saying.
 
Last edited:
nortatoga

nortatoga

.338 Win Mag
Monthly Donor
Messages
8,341
Reaction score
18,935
Location
Saratoga County
One thing to remember these applications are legal documents, Can you answer all the question truthfully? Also NYS drives license or NYS ID is required.
 
M

mystery

.177 BB
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
USA
nortatoga said:
One thing to remember these applications are legal documents, Can you answer all the question truthfully? Also NYS drives license or NYS ID is required.
Click to expand...
What question do you think is an issue?

Is there a definition of "residence" or "resident" in any of the NY state laws?

Regarding, NYS drivers license or ID, I dont think it is required. I think that part-time residents in NYC have gotten permits supplying their out-of-state DL/ID. How else would it work if NY/NYC is your part-time residence and you have your DL/ID in your primary state?
 
nortatoga

nortatoga

.338 Win Mag
Monthly Donor
Messages
8,341
Reaction score
18,935
Location
Saratoga County
mystery said:
What question do you think is an issue?

Is there a definition of "residence" or "resident" in any of the NY state laws?

Regarding, NYS drivers license or ID, I dont think it is required. I think that part-time residents in NYC have gotten permits supplying their out-of-state DL/ID. How else would it work if NY/NYC is your part-time residence and you have your DL/ID in your primary state?
Click to expand...

The State application is standard, What the County application asks may be different County to County? NYC is a whole different story! Have you looked at the NYC application? I have not so I make no comment on that.
 
nortatoga

nortatoga

.338 Win Mag
Monthly Donor
Messages
8,341
Reaction score
18,935
Location
Saratoga County
An example my County Saratoga requires you to bring with you at time of appointment
Drivers license or a Utility bill ( only if driver license does not so current address ) it is little thing like these that could snag you! And like I said each County is different!
 
Robin

Robin

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
19,974
Reaction score
43,171
Location
Livingston County
Monroe county Clerk, a permit holder, was on the radio the other day and said they have cleaned up the back log and it shouldn't take more than three months. The biggest slowdown is the background check, not in the authorities doing them, but the provided references not responding, choose wisely. The second hang up is the judge and he had no explanation for why that is. Total turnaround in his office after receiving is 24-48 hours, and for redirecting from law enforcement to the judge is again 24-48 hours.
He also stated that right now things have slowed a bit because of the number of permit holders in the office trying to clean up their permit and or asking questions relative to the recertification bullshit (my word). Sounds like The county clerk is not part of the problem at least for Monroe.
Robin
 
Criticalt

Criticalt

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,575
Reaction score
16,192
Location
WNY
Robin said:
Monroe county Clerk, a permit holder, was on the radio the other day and said they have cleaned up the back log and it shouldn't take more than three months. The biggest slowdown is the background check, not in the authorities doing them, but the provided references not responding, choose wisely. The second hang up is the judge and he had no explanation for why that is. Total turnaround in his office after receiving is 24-48 hours, and for redirecting from law enforcement to the judge is again 24-48 hours.
He also stated that right now things have slowed a bit because of the number of permit holders in the office trying to clean up their permit and or asking questions relative to the recertification bullshit (my word). Sounds like The county clerk is not part of the problem at least for Monroe.
Robin
Click to expand...
Our county pp office has a "Repeal the SafeAct" sign on their door. The office is in the county building.
 
Celt

Celt

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
9,597
Reaction score
19,751
Location
Westchester
Suffolk sucks, so does nassau and wastechester. Best of the 3, perhaps wastechester.
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

.950 JDJ
Messages
34,194
Reaction score
38,648
Location
Western NY
I know some folks in alleghany county and it’s cheap and they said 2-4 weeks no restrictions. I’m not sure, but I don’t think they are perfect people either.
 
Mr. terzmo

Mr. terzmo

.308 Win
Messages
3,169
Reaction score
3,211
Location
Pendleton NY
I've only dealt with one and heard experiences with another and their system. Niagara County has the nicest people to work with on a permit. They make me feel as my feelings on handguns are the same as theirs. Like working with "good" family. Now Erie county I hear alot of horror stories for actions after plus getting approved takes a long time. 18 months for a close friend for a hunting/target only. KUDO'S Niagara County

Just wish the DMV would be the same
 
kgun12

kgun12

6.5 Creedmoor
U.S. Military
Messages
1,634
Reaction score
2,007
Location
North Olmsted Ohio
Ontario, was pretty easy to get and amendments were made on the spot even if you wanted the plastic permit. Livingston was like 10 days, start to finish.
 
dubleuhb

dubleuhb

.308 Win
Messages
2,864
Reaction score
5,329
Location
Undecided
I think he's only asking about the 3 specific counties he listed.....anyway never been to those three so I gots nuttin.
 
K

Kiknmann

22lr
Messages
24
Reaction score
10
Location
Westchester
mystery said:
CT and NYC resident. Have CT, MA, UT, FL permits, no restrictions. RI in progress. Would like to carry in NY state / NYC, know its a long shot for NYC. Trying to figure out if I should try to obtain premises permits in NY and NYC first and then try to convert into carry (does that require re-applying?) or try to do NY state carry first and then try to get a special carry for NYC (out of city validation) as I dont think they will validate any of my other permits? MA is typically not easy to get non-resident non-restricted but I referenced my career history (included investigating cyber criminals / financial crimes) and being threatened before and they approved without question.

For NY state, I have a boat that I use as a residence 7-8 months of the year and do spend time in NY, living on the boat, usually on rented moorings or transient docks. I read the recent ruling, and at quick glance I did see it mention "owning" a residence... would someone renting be restricted? I can see a case being made if I get a mooring permit in my name, buy mooring tackle, and have dropped in either Westchester, Nassau, or Suffolk county, allowing me to hook-up my boat and spend indefinite amounts of time living on my boat in one of those counties.

I am trying to figure out which of those three counties is easiest for a part-time resident to obtain a carry permit? I can probably more easily get character references in Nassau county but could potentially find in Westchester & Suffolk as well.

Thank you for your thoughts!
Click to expand...
 
Criticalt

Criticalt

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,575
Reaction score
16,192
Location
WNY
Saltwater60 said:
I know some folks in alleghany county and it’s cheap and they said 2-4 weeks no restrictions. I’m not sure, but I don’t think they are perfect people either.
Click to expand...
Allegheny, Cattaraugus and Chautauqua are all very easy and very short times. All unrestricted.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top