I once had a really nice DS Arms Stg58 Para.Had someone at a party recently trying to sell me a FAL with 5 20 round mags for 2gs. If only I wasn't so worried about felonies
It was my favorite gun at the time. Its hard to say exactly since its been 10 years since I owned the FAL but I do belive I like the Galil better. I definitely prefer it to any G3/CETME type I've fired as well as any M1A type. I never fired a SCAR though and I think that is the only real competition this gun has, with the SCAR prolly being tge better of the two, conditionally. I'm not a bullpup fan so I won't speak to the KelTec RFB nor the intriguing Desert Tech MDR.
All of which is a moot point since in NYS the only viable option for a short semi auto .308 carbine is an M1A SOCOM, or whatever Bastardized AR10 type you could have.