Temporary Restaining Order Issued For Concealed Carry Improvement Act (merged thread)

maverick52

maverick52

.223 Rem
Messages
1,114
Reaction score
2,197
Location
Knowhere
Glock_USA said:
The part I find interesting is they say not to be deterred to re-file with them if the 2ND doesn't give an explanation in a reasonable amount of time. They don't say come back if you dont get your way. So if it stands it's good as long as the 2ND explains why? Seems that way to me. They don't say let the lower court fix it. They say let them explain to you why it is what it is.
Click to expand...
Here is what I think they are saying. They are giving the 2nd a warning. If the 2nd drags this out or doesn’t rule in our favor than we can appeal to SCOTUS. I suspect the 2nd will decide by end of the month.
 
G

Glock_USA

.45 acp
Messages
379
Reaction score
637
Location
NY
maverick52 said:
Here is what I think they are saying. They are giving the 2nd a warning. If the 2nd drags this out or doesn’t rule in our favor than we can appeal to SCOTUS. I suspect the 2nd will decide by end of the month.
Click to expand...
More games. If they are going to decide then decide now. Where did all of that "one day is one too many" talk go?
 
US RIFLE M1A

US RIFLE M1A

.45 acp
Messages
361
Reaction score
888
Location
PA/NY Border in NEPA
There is a serious reason that the Supreme Court rarely issues interlocutory appeals.

If they (SCOTUS) lifts the stay, then the 2nd Circuit hears the next phase of the case and re-applies the stay, then what just happened?

What has happened is that the 2nd Circuit has effectively over-ruled SCOTUS.

They (SCOTUS) cannot let that happen. They have to be the final legal word.

This appeal to SCOTUS was always a long-shot, and the best that we could have hoped for was to get their attention in the matter. Presumably we did that.

EDIT: an interlocutory appeal is an appeal on one decision within an ongoing case whose full resolution has not yet been arrived at.
 
Last edited:
G

Glock_USA

.45 acp
Messages
379
Reaction score
637
Location
NY
US RIFLE M1A

US RIFLE M1A

.45 acp
Messages
361
Reaction score
888
Location
PA/NY Border in NEPA
maverick52 said:
Here is what I think they are saying. They are giving the 2nd a warning. If the 2nd drags this out or doesn’t rule in our favor than we can appeal to SCOTUS. I suspect the 2nd will decide by end of the month.
Click to expand...
I clearly see more than that. The two justices have already taken sides and agree with Judges Suddaby and Sinatra. (and Judge Bumb presumably.)
 
G

Glock_USA

.45 acp
Messages
379
Reaction score
637
Location
NY
US RIFLE M1A said:
I clearly see more than that. The two justices have already taken sides and agree with Judges Suddaby and Sinatra.
Click to expand...
Any reason everyone didn't jump on board here? The original 6 voters in Bruen? Does this kind of say if it were to go back to them we only have support form these 2 now?
 
John Stark

John Stark

.44 mag
Messages
940
Reaction score
2,746
Location
IAM
Breaking News! SCOTUS released a further statement clarifying their stance:

"We understand that NY is trying to bend NYers over and are flagrantly violating their Constitutional Rights, but we must go on with the charade and allow lower courts and the States to flaunt our rulings WE ALREADY MADE IN BRUEN because we are toothless and without the means of enforcing anything...

Hopefully no one gets arrested, Red Flagged, raided, and/or shot while we continue to ponder these weighty matters!"

PS. NYers can find very reasonably priced lube on Amazon! Text Go Scotus for an... 80% discount on all lubricating products! (Offer expires on July 4th, so hurry!)"
Click to expand...

Whew! Almost seemed like the State of NY was winning this legal battle. My faith in government has been restored!
 
Last edited:
US RIFLE M1A

US RIFLE M1A

.45 acp
Messages
361
Reaction score
888
Location
PA/NY Border in NEPA
Glock: It's not time yet. The pieces are not in place for SCOTUS to issue a broad, definitive ruling. At this point , they could only say: 'OK stay lifted.' See below.

Mav: I hope so. I believe the game is headed that way and I would be surprised otherwise.

My opinion: Alito and Thomas realize that this is a shitshow and I cannot imagine they are not lining up for a smackdown. Not only do they have to dump the CCIA, they have to prevent the lefty states from pulling this crap ad infinitum. At this point there is just not enough material to work with coming out of the 2nd Circuit to smack down. They issued a clear warning to the 2nd to not only do their job, but to do it in a timely manner and with respect for Bruen. And that they stand with Suddaby and Sinatra.
 
maverick52

maverick52

.223 Rem
Messages
1,114
Reaction score
2,197
Location
Knowhere
@US RIFLE M1A
You are spot on. I see this is an indirect warning to the circuit courts and see three possible outcomes
1. The 2nd Circuit vacates the stay
2. They keep the stay and we appeal to Alito and Thomas and get the smack down
3. They take too long and we appeal again ti Alito and Thomas for smack down.

The other circuit courts are in check too. I see this all working for good. It will be a little longer but I do think we will be victorious.
 
G

GlockModel29

.40 S&W
Messages
143
Reaction score
264
Location
Sand Lake, NY
maverick52 said:
I agree. The 2nd knows it too. Despite all the negativity, I see blood in the water and think we are going to have a big win.
Click to expand...
John Stark said:
Breaking News! SCOTUS released a further statement clarifying their stance:



Whew! Almost seemed like the State of NY was winning this legal battle. My faith in government has been restored!
Click to expand...
I'm sure rose colored glasses are already out of stock on Amazon.
 
JunkBoxFull

JunkBoxFull

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
1,519
Reaction score
2,649
Location
Movin On
And just to think, all these parasites are sucking the life out of all those tax funds we all pay, to delay & deny our rights.

Its not "their money", so they don`t care. Hell they even feed their faces, have lavish party`s, off your tax dollars.

This all just a shit show, and we`re all paying for it. And they will just keep right on doing it.

Surely more unconstitutional laws are on the way from these parasites!

We`ve allowed this for 250yrs. Just`Us, Rinse & Repeat.
 
G

GlockModel29

.40 S&W
Messages
143
Reaction score
264
Location
Sand Lake, NY
maverick52 said:
Not rose colored glasses. Reading between the lines of what happened. Time will tell who is wearing rose colored glasses and who is wearing black stained glasses.
Click to expand...
You can read between the lines all you want. The funny thing is, if SCOTUS would have vacated the stay, the same people in here would be screaming how HUGE of a victory it was....
 
G

Glock_USA

.45 acp
Messages
379
Reaction score
637
Location
NY
I can't see the 2nd circuit just rolling over and doing anything different just because 2 guys of SCOTUS wrote a letter saying come back later. Why would they? If they reverse it and rule in our favor we are given back our rights. But if they don't then MAYBE SCOTUS picks it back up and MAYBE they have enough votes to restore our rights. There were only 2 justices that got on board with the letter. Why wouldn't the 2nd circuit take their chances? It would be better than giving us what we want right now. Maybe it wouldn't happen for a year or 2 or maybe it would never happen. They'll roll the dice and we'll suffer in the meantime.
 
G

GlockModel29

.40 S&W
Messages
143
Reaction score
264
Location
Sand Lake, NY
Glock_USA said:
I can't see the 2nd circuit just rolling over and doing anything different just because 2 guys of SCOTUS wrote a letter saying come back later. Why would they? If they reverse it and rule in our favor we are given back our rights. But if they don't then MAYBE SCOTUS picks it back up and MAYBE they have enough votes to restore our rights. There were only 2 justices that got on board with the letter. Why wouldn't the 2nd circuit take their chances? It would be better than giving us what we want right now. Maybe it wouldn't happen for a year or 2 or maybe it would never happen. They'll roll the dice and we'll suffer in the meantime.
Click to expand...
I 100% agree with you!!!
 
JunkBoxFull

JunkBoxFull

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
1,519
Reaction score
2,649
Location
Movin On
If the SCOTUS has to decide, it stands for the whole country. Maybe that is what they are waiting for.

But in the mean time, time and tax dollars are being wasted playing cat-n-mouse games back and forth.

tumblr_o5y4zky7Zd1tyncywo1_400.gif
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

.950 JDJ
Messages
33,168
Reaction score
37,316
Location
Western NY
CaliberPlus said:
I still wanna :puke:You guys have more faith in this than I do at this point.
Click to expand...
I have no faith in no one except God and most of my immediate family members and a few friends. I have zero faith in the courts, our government, or our politicians. I stocked up and took care of myself in the Buffalo Blizzard and I’ve done what I could to prepare for this.
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

.950 JDJ
Messages
33,168
Reaction score
37,316
Location
Western NY
Glock_USA said:
I can't see the 2nd circuit just rolling over and doing anything different just because 2 guys of SCOTUS wrote a letter saying come back later. Why would they? If they reverse it and rule in our favor we are given back our rights. But if they don't then MAYBE SCOTUS picks it back up and MAYBE they have enough votes to restore our rights. There were only 2 justices that got on board with the letter. Why wouldn't the 2nd circuit take their chances? It would be better than giving us what we want right now. Maybe it wouldn't happen for a year or 2 or maybe it would never happen. They'll roll the dice and we'll suffer in the meantime.
Click to expand...
I agree. The second circuit will toss us a few bones and hope we don’t go to scotus or cause a delay. The longer they delay the more likely the courts make up will shift. This is the beginning of the end for us and our rights. Brien will mean nothing without enforcement and without a conservative majority on the court. The court said we got Roe V Wade wrong and the liberals when they are back in charge will say we got NYSRPA V Bruen wrong and we’re back to the two step validation process or worse. It may take 5 years, maybe 10 years but it will happen. Get ready and be ready.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top