maverick52
.223 Rem
Hoping for the next part of the case. It’s cyclical sarcasm.
Will the CCIA be Enjoined this Week? Case dismissed
- Thread starter maverick52
- Start date
Packman297
9mm
I just read the opinion. The judge basically agreed with the plaintiffs on all issues, but claimed he was forced to deny the injunction on procedural grounds - lack of standing and an improperly identified defendant.
One the one hand, it’s kind of BS. On the other, it should be pretty easy to fix, I would think.
One the one hand, it’s kind of BS. On the other, it should be pretty easy to fix, I would think.
Saltwater60
20×102mm Vulcan
He probably could have done that some time ago though. I’m pretty pissed actually. He dicked around and les everyone on that he would rule on it and we’ll he did rule on it, but certainly not what we were hoping for. I guess we will see and I’m not sure how this isn’t in his jurisdiction since it impacts the entire USA. I admittedly don’t know a ton about judicial law or what jurisdiction are.
kev74
20×102mm Vulcan
It's still good for red flags and marking you as an undesirable.
Yup and become a better plantiff
Dr. Evil
20×102mm Vulcan
Surprised? No, nothing surprises me in this shit stain of a state. Disappointed is more the feeling. Also grateful. Grateful that I am getting myself out of here.
Or he spent the time trying to try and find standing for the Plantiffs
C3D
.338 Win Mag
This was all a ploy to force the case to be refiled so it can be moved to an Obama appointed judge.
stokes
.338 Win Mag
Unfortunately it wont be long before this kind of bullshit follows you. As they used to say, "this country is going to hell in a hand basket"
Same crap different day. The court is not going to save anyone from the politicians the people put into office. (I know the current resident of the governor’s mansion was not elected to her current post but she was elected to the lt governor’s office.)
US RIFLE M1A
.45 acp
Two things: One, he declared Antonyuk the presumptive winner of the case, but did not grant standing. Two, he said that he was able to use interest balancing due to this being an injunction, not the real case. If it were a real case, a plaintiff with the same arguments and standing would have won.
It IS a loss, but it is not a wipeout. Much of the decision is a road map for the next step. This is going to be a long road, it always is.
However, be reminded of two other facts: SCOTUS opens in a month, and concealed is concealed.
It IS a loss, but it is not a wipeout. Much of the decision is a road map for the next step. This is going to be a long road, it always is.
However, be reminded of two other facts: SCOTUS opens in a month, and concealed is concealed.
Dr. Evil
20×102mm Vulcan
Longer than it is now though. I do believe some states will put up much more of a fight than the dolts here in NYS.
Egret-II
.40 S&W
You're just a felon waiting to happen...
Saltwater60
20×102mm Vulcan
Yes SCOTUS a opens in a month and Biden is already planning to add four of the most liberal judges we’ve ever seen. I think this will encourage him to do that. If they win the senate in November You can bet they will make a move.
John Stark
.44 mag
They strung this case along until the last minute knowing they had this in their pocket and the law was going in effect. Its a rigged game, but hey keep your figures crossed!
Who knew Hochul likes to play football on top of all of her other important duties as she goes about making sure we are all very, very Safe?
Go watch her video announcing the new Tyranny that goes in effect a few hours from now, she's all smiles and obviously knows the fix is in. In NY, the fix is always in.
Last edited:
Steal2B
.700 Nitro Express
Unsubscribed from the endless GOA fund raising messaging.
mca90guitar
.357 mag
Fuck this place.
Egret-II
.40 S&W
The thing about saying "fuck it" to unconstitutional laws is that if you get caught carrying in a "sensitive place" you'll become a felon. I don't think anyone is willing to gamble with their freedom like that.
livingston
20×102mm Vulcan
I am sure this will be covered in great detail 8 PM tonight WYSL 1040 Schedule
Second Amendment Radio Show on WYSL, 1040 AM, 92.1 FM and 95.5 FM. We are on their stations every Monday, Wednesday at 8 PM, Saturday and Sunday at 6 PM.
Tune In on Mondays, Wednesdays at 8 pm , Saturdays and Sundays 6:00 pm
Tune In on Mondays, Wednesdays at 8 pm , Saturdays and Sundays 6:00 pm
carpediem
.338 Win Mag
whatupbo
9mm
Does anybody honestly think that this cunt flinched even once with these lawsuits against her and the law? No she didn’t because she knows the fix is in , the four other lawsuits are going to play out exactly the same way.
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
Here I was being all cute and shit thinking it was just going to be a handshake and an envelope. Who was I kidding ? I’m sure It was more like ,
maverick52
.223 Rem
Honestly I feel like crap. I hear the optimists looking for the good in all this. But I’m also fed up with losing all the time. Now we wait for the next case. NYSRPA vs Bruen part 2
S&W Fan
.475 A&M Magnum
Buh by .. Peckerwood
RBean
.40 S&W
Scanned the opinion. Did not read in detail. The judge punted on 3rd down. Could have found "standing" if he wanted to. But case dismissed without prejudice. Don't worry. Within a few months of this monstrosity in effect there will be plenty of people with standing. People who were arrested because they have not paid attention to the changes; some one who stops at the wrong gas station on the way to the range, people who are denied permits, people whose permits are delayed because the County Clerks and licensing officers are totally confused etc.
I lost two motions for preliminary injunctions in gun cases but went on the win the cases eventually. All is not lost. Also, a denial of a constitutional right is in and of itself irreparable harm.
I would not appeal this decision, just find a plaintiff who does have standing. Should be able to do that in a few weeks. Glad I retired to Florida so personally not my problem.
I lost two motions for preliminary injunctions in gun cases but went on the win the cases eventually. All is not lost. Also, a denial of a constitutional right is in and of itself irreparable harm.
I would not appeal this decision, just find a plaintiff who does have standing. Should be able to do that in a few weeks. Glad I retired to Florida so personally not my problem.
Last edited:
Cavalry
.338 Win Mag
4th box of liberty for the win. Just kidding Stasi officer, see you in the next round of court.
Saltwater60
20×102mm Vulcan
I don’t get the this guy doesn’t have standing thing, I mean I do I just disagree with it. He will be impeached and effected by the sensitive places ruling I don’t see how or why you need to be arrested first.
gunpoliticsny
6.5 Creedmoor
Dr. Evil
20×102mm Vulcan
For now. The hack is taking a victory lap.
The CCIA goes into effect on September 1 after Attorney General James successfully defended its constitutionality.
